QOTR Quarter Finals - Taylor Wilde vs Melina

This yearly tournament is held to determine which woman had the most significant year, according to her accomplishments, improvement in wrestling skills and character portrayal, and how the fans perceive her, regardless of whether or not booking favored her.

In this match, you will be voting for TAYLOR WILDE orMELINA

TAYLOR WILDE’s 2009 Highlights:
- first woman to become TNA Women’s Knockout Champion and TNA Knockout Tag Team Champion
- one-half of the inaugural TNA Knockout Tag Team Champions
- competed in the first ever Knockout Monster’s Ball and Knockout “Match of 10,000 Tacks”


MELINA’s 2009 Highlights:
- currently the WWE Divas Champion
- one of three women to hold Women’s and Divas Championship (only one to win both in the same year)
- one of the two survivors in the Survivor Series diva elimination tag team match



Vote and discuss! Thank you for participating in this year’s tournament!

I am gonna give my vote to Taylor Wilde who been in some very amazing matches this year and continues to impress. Melina also been having a good year so I think this will be close.

im going with Taylor too, shes had some very good moments,
Melina is the only diva to win both titles within the space of a year, but shes also been a very boring diva to watch, and her latest stint on Raw has been nothing but a flop

I voted Melina (biasedly) because I really want to see a showdown between her and Michelle but congrats to Taylor if she wins this, she has had a great year

this is why these tournement are stupid.
you SHOULDNT vote biasedly, just to have a showdown with michelle
if you want a showdown with michelle, make a damn thread in the divas section saying "who has had a better year"

Fuck off LL! as ssilva said, Melina has some haters so if I wanted to give her a pity vote then so be it. I actually think she had a good year (although boring) but so is Taylor (she's dull) but winning two championships in one year is unusual for the ladies so I went with Melina because

A-She had the better year
B-I really want to see her go against Michelle

Blue Campbell wrote:

Fuck off LL! as ssilva said, Melina has some haters so if I wanted to give her a pity vote then so be it. I actually think she had a good year (although boring) but so is Taylor (she's dull) but winning two championships in one year is unusual for the ladies so I went with Melina because

A-She had the better year
B-I really want to see her go against Michelle

Know what? Just a couple of weeks ago you said how Taylor is exciting again...and now she's dull again?? Jeez man, make up your mind already.

You caught me! I actually like Taylor these days

Blue Campbell wrote:

You caught me! I actually like Taylor these days

Your an idiot you know that?

I voted for Melina. I agree with ssilva.

Raw may not be treating Melina well now but When she was on SD, She was in awesome matches, her feud with Beth before the draft was amazing.

if you thought Melina had the better year, then why not say that in the first damn place, rather then proove that your an idiot who just wants stupid show downs, rather then choose the correct person
you said biasedly, which prooves your and idiot, cos it shouldnt be biased
so no i wont fuck off

I suppose I should have worded things differently.

i think taylor has had a very good year! she is the tna knockout tag team champion! and she has also had very good matches!

i do not like melina very much! her fans think she is so good but she is not!

Taylor had a pretty great year. Melina's was just meh. Taylor for the win.