WD's Next Top Model- Final Challenge Judge's Discussion *judges only post here*

All pictures from the Challenges will be posted in here and us, the judges's, will comment on each picture.

Once you have a chance to view and comment all of the pictures. Send me a PM of your bottom 3 pictures.

Models
LL has Layla Eliminated Challenge 9
LH has Savannah Eliminated Challenge 6
Joe has Sunny Eliminated Challenge 1
Janine has Natalya Eliminated Challenge 8
Kas has Mickie James Eliminated Challenge 10
Hailey has Maryse Eliminated Challenge 11
Blue has Christy Hemme Eliminated Challenge 5
Mia has Michelle McCool Eliminated Challenge 4
Minterz has Melina
Slick has Trish Stratus Eliminated Challenge 3
Venom has Beth Phoenix
Pedro has Eve Torres Eliminated Challenge 9
Quisee has Lacey Von Erich Eliminated Challenge 2
Angel has Alicia Fox Eliminated Challenge 8
Divattic has Sable Eliminated Challenge 7

Judges
Meshell
Vixen Resigned
Keri
Tank Added Challenge 3


Judges will give the players a task and we have to find a photo that meets their demands. Three judges then announce the bottom three and debate in private of which one should get eliminated. This continues until one model/player is left standing

No the judges pick the bottom 3. And Blue Judges only please

Oh ok! I'll delete my posts.

Spoiler:

Thanks Vix!

NP..ok my comments:

Mickie - love the attire and the snow falling but the tan on Mickie isnt doing her any justice.

Maryse - love the attire colors, different from the traditional red and white combo.

Layla - very flattering pic that shows off all her best features

Eve - love the pose

Savannah - I dont like the attire, cute pose though

Lacey - sexy pic but I think she has slightly too much makeup on

Natalya - I love the pose and her hair color especially. the dark chair was a good choice

Michelle - I'm 50/50 on the attire. the little green bows look odd to me. Nice pose though

Melina - the tree in the background was a cute touch. I love the gloves. very elegant

Trish - i dont like the attire.

Sable - she looks a little too tanned. the facial expression is sexy though. Attire is ok, could've been better

Sunny - love the dress and shoes

Beth - I love the dress but the pose is weird. It's like she's trying too hard to be sexy and we already know she's sexy.

Christy - love the background. good pic

Alicia - not liking the hair or attire but i like the pose

Were missing 2 pictures. Blue's and Angel's, aka Christy and Alicia.

ok i'll add them...wont take long

ok added...Christy is in the spoiler lol

Mickie: Not sure if thats snow or something hanging off her panies, either way not cute. the facial expression is also off, and the bra dont go with it either. besides that it a good pic, 7/10

Maryse: im not sure if shes trying to be an elf or a green santa. not cute either way. not a fan of the skirt. 6/10

Layla: Great pic, love the messy hair makes it looks like santas been busy. outfit nice, great pose for the ass. 10/10

eve: Not to xmasy so a point goes there. otherwise pretty good. 9/10

Asian chick from ecw: Not a fan of the socks and boot combo. it looks goofy, also can do without the cotton balls on the dress. 7/10

Lacey: not a great pose, the box covering half the outfit doesnt make it a good pic to judge. since im just going by the top it will have to be 5/10

Nattie: no xmasy besides the hat so i had to take off a point. great pose, just with a bit more color next time 8/10

McCool: not a fan of the small bag shes carrying, santa should have a big one. otherwise i like 9/10

Melina: not a cute xmas dress, the had looks cheap too, and the pose makes her look like shes trying to hard. 4/10

Trish: Not really a pose pic, but the attire is ok. 7/10

Sable: Santa looks like a hoe, attire kinda to fuzzy for my taste but i love the hat. 7/10

Beth: Took a point off cause its not xmas colored/ 9/10

Alicia: Again, love the messy hair. love the pose and love the 2 piece outfit with a little candy cane in the center. shows off her body great 10/10

christy: love the spikes and the necklace added to the santa suit, its like santa meets punk. 10/10

forgot sunny: not a fan of the outfit, not really holiday besides the color. 2/10

Mickie- The attire and pose is cute. Im not so big on the facial expression and the tan is too dark.

Maryse- Love the attire, except for the gloves, im not feeling them. Otherwise great photo.

Layla- Great pose and attire. Even the messy hair looks great!

Eve- Hot pose, and hot attire. Enough said.

Savannah- I like the pose, Savannah also has a great smile. The attire is nice, but im not feeling the stockings or the boots.

Lacey- Great photo, the only thing I dislike about it is the present. Only because it really doesn't match what she's wearing.

Natalya- Fantastic pose and outfit. Love how the hair color also matches with the look.

Michelle- Cute attire, cute pose, and pretty smile.

Melina- For some reason this picture reminds me of Minnie Mouse, especially with the polka dot dress and the white gloves, lol. Non the less it still fits the theme and its cute.

Trish- Not feeling the attire, or the quality of the phote. But the picture does show how Trish walks down the runway.

Sable- Her facial expression is sexy. And her attire is ok.

Sunny- Photo doesn't show much of her face. I do like the shoes though.

Beth- Cute pose. Love the attire, gold looks great on her.

Christy- Her hair looks amazing. Her attire is great. And she has a great smile.

Alicia- I do like the green on her. I dont like the pose though.

Comments: Challenge #2

Layla- Cute little black dress, that shows Layla's shape. I'm not really feeling the hair though.

Savannah- I like the dress and pose. She has great accessories too.

Natalya- Cute LBD, great smile and hair is nice.

Mickie- Loving the dress and shoes, and the necklace makes the dress even better.

Maryse- I'm really not liking the attire. It would be better, imo, without the cover. But the red looks great.

Christy- Love the dress, and the color goes great with her skin tone. Hair looks great too.

Michelle- Cute dress and pose.

Melina- The dress is really pretty and it looks really nice on Melina.

Trish- Really nice evening gown. Looks nice on here, and nice pose.

Beth- Awesome dress, hair, pose, and accessories. Great picture all around.

Eve- Loving the dress and shoes. Overall great picture.

Lacey- Not really what we were looking for with the theme. But its still a nice picture.

Alicia- Im not really liking the pose or picture, but I do like the dress.

Sable- Im not really sure if this is a bathing suit cover or a dress. So I'm not really liking the picture.

Maybe the judges aren't posting cause of the topic title. Shouldn't u change it to Challenge 2 now? Just saying sorry for posting here I know it's for Judges.

Thats ok. Thanks Pedro. I forgot to change it.

layla: eh not feeling it. to simple from the hair and the outfit. 4/10

savannah: the scarf makes it looks to casual. cant really tell if the hair is ok. 3/10

Nattie: Hair still a bit simple but the dress and the shoes are adorable. 7/10

Mickie: not a fan of the dress, but it looks cute and it isnt simple like the other chicks. 7/10

maryse: she looks like a fucking drape. good color on her but horrible dress. 4/10

Christy: Face and dress are horrible. 3/10

Michelle: hair is simple, cant see the whole dress. 2/10

Melina: like the hair, hate the dress. its trying to be casual but look like a night gown. 4/10

Trish: thats a teddy not a dress. 0/10

Beth: Nice dress and hair but not her style. it makes her look fake. 3/10

Eve: nice dress, hair a bit simple. 7/10

Lacey: not really an evening outfit. 0/10

Alicia: love the dress, hair a bit simple. 4/10

Sable: a bit dated but it fits. 6/10

maryse: love the jeans hate the belt and the boots. 7/10
Sable: mom jeans, nuff said. 2/10
christy: the rips are ok, but im not sure what the square things on the side are. 6/10
Trish: not a fan, the zip makes it look like shes packing a penis and the button makes it look ugly. pose is ok. 3/10
Angela: not a fan of the hair or jacket. a simple tank top would of been better. 7/10.
Beth: a bit plain. 6/10
Eve: love it. 10/10
layla: the top doesnt cover her well. 5/10
alicia: not a fan of the hair or shoes. she looks a bit like shes talking to the flower that also match into the background. 4/10
Melina: when did she become native american? not a fan of the shirt or hair. 6/10
Nattie: the pic makes her look a lot softer then most of her pics. that doesnt mean i like the outfit at all. 3/10
Michelle: almost perfect, not a fan of the jacket. 9/10
Mickie: did she rip her own jeans? she also looks crazy. 5/10

maryse: Nice Pic, don't really understand the point of the ladder.

Sable: WOW! Horrible picture, I'm sorry but I hate everything about it. Looks like she only has one eye, and her pants are almost touching her bra, not a good look.

christy: This pose is reall awkward to me, her ribs are sticking out further then her chest, the ripped up jeans look a little stupid.

Trish:Decent pic, could have been better though.

Angela: I like the whole "Just a girl next door" kinda feel

Beth: I have that same pair of jeans, nice pose! It's amazing how scary and power she looks in the ring, but really soft and girly outside.

Eve:WOW! BEST PICTURE IN THE GROUP!! SHE IS WERKING EVERYTHING IN THIS PICTURE!

layla: I like the pose and the expression! it all just seems to be working.

alicia: Looks a little Ellie May Clampish, would have been nice to see her looking at the camera
Melina: I love it! The length of the body and the pose is great!

Nattie:Sorry, It's just not working, I'm not liking the face,pose, or outfit.

Michelle: I like the seductiveness of it.

Mickie: I like it, could have better though.

Maryse- I like everything about this photo except the background. Love the boots.

Sable- Im not really liking this picture either. Looks too old.

Christy- Sexy pose. Nice use of jeans.

Trish- This kinda reminds me of a 'Got Milk' pose without the milk mustache. Great hair and smile though.

Angela- I think the belt makes the picture. It makes the whole attire look nice.

Beth- Nice pose for her. Love the shirt and shoes.

Eve- Agreeing with the other 2 judges. This is the best picture. Everything about this photo is great!

Layla- I like the attire. But the whole facial look and microphone is throwing it off for me.

Alicia- I love this picture. I think the whole thing is great. The pose, the jeans, the hair, and the shoes.

Melina- I think that this is a great picture of Melina. The whole look with the attire looks nice.

Nattie- Im really not liking the picture either. It just looks all plain to me.

Michelle- Sexy pose, and attire. Great picture.

Mickie- This picture of Mickie is really cute. She reminds me of a little kid in it, lol.

Savannah- It's cute and simple, I like it.

Alicia- Looks like a cabbage patch kid all grown up. lol

Maryse- I don't really like this picture, the designs on the sides is ugly, the cape thing seems pointless, the top is kinda nice.

Beth- I love this picture, I like the little Sailor Moon head band.

Sable- FINALLY!!! A cute Sable picture! I love the pose.

Christy- The left side of her face looks a little sloopy, like it's about to melt, but the body and pose is cute.

Mickie- Not gold, but close enough...I like the pose and the bikini

Layla- Everything below the neck looks good, her face looks weird, she's doing too much with it.

Eve- Her face is always FLAWLESS!! Not as good as last weeks pic, but still nice.

Natalya- WOW! My favorite picture of the week!!! I have that jacket! everything in this picture is kinda plan and simple but it's all working together, to really help her stand out and shine!

Melina- She looks like a golden flamingo, it's a cute picture.

Michelle- The pose looks awkward, and she looks uncomfortable in the face.

cut me outta this again and i will hunt u guys down.

Asian chick: it looks kinda nude on her, not cute at all. the shoes save it from being in the bottom 3 though. 4/10
Alicia: not cute at all, the hair the outfit it doesnt go well together. 0
Maryse: she looks slightly dumb, like a sorority chick whos on the pole for the 1st time. 2/10
Beth: stunning, the best this photo shoot. 10/10
Sable: i like boobs but fuck that. eh not a FAN. 2/10
Christy: thats how you do a beach photo shoot. 8/10
Mickie: thats yellow, u fail. 0
layla: her cheeks scare me. 6/10
Eve: good, second best. 9/10
Nattie: not a fan of the shirt but the vest rocks. 7/10
Melina: you would be jeff hardy if he had a vag and boobs. not a fan of the pose either. 5/10
Michelle: looks a bit shocked, and the pose not so good but otherwise good. 6/10

Challenge #5

Mickie: not a fan of army attire, and where the hell is pink in nature. u fail yet again mickie. 3/10

maryse: looks fake in the face, like shes trying to be sexy and nice at the same time but the sexy doesnt come out. outfits a bit simple for her, but it is an ok pic. 6/10

Asian chick: she looks nude again. not cute. 2/10.

Sable: looks like a tranny. 0

Layla: thank god her hair isnt like that anymore. 7/10

Beth: those eyes are scary. 6/10, u would of gotten a 10 if it didnt look like beth wanted to posses my soul.

Christy: 1/10. not a fan of the outfit or the pic.

Nattie: bottoms cute, top not. pose is great. 6/10

Eve: much like beth the eyes scare me. 5/10

Melina: not a fan of the hair, but everyting else is good. 7/10

Alicia: not a fan of the hair either. 6/10

Mickie- Cute Bikini, it goes nice with her tan.

Maryse- Cute Bikini, cute pose, and the background makes the photo.

Savannah- Tans darkers then the bikini so its easy to see, which is cute, and I like the pose and the background.

Sable- One of the best pics of her that we've seen this seaon so far. I wish there was a better background tho.

Layla- Cute pic and bikini, but I really hate her hair like that, lol.

Beth- The orange bikini goes nice with her tan and blonde hair.

Christy- I'll be honest, this picture sucks compared to the ones in the past challenges. There is really nothing nice I can say about this pic.

Nattie- I like the color and I like how shes in water. But I still would like to see more of her in the picture.

Eve- Perfect picture.

Melina- Like Me-Shell, love the picture and bikini, and surroundings. But not a fan of the hair this time.

Alicia- The green looks great with her skin tone.

Mickie- Looks like she's trying to secretly sniff her underarms, this picture is ok, but ti's not really doing anything for me.

Maryse- I don't like the face.

Savannah- I like it, it's like she's really soaking in the sun

Sable- Meh, it's not the worst picture of her, but it's certainly not the best, it's like she's wearing granny panties thongs.

Layla- DAMN!!!!! Why to really step it up, I love this picture, she did the damn thang in this picture.

Beth- WOW!! I LOVE IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Christy- That wall looks sick, I'm a little afraid of her being that close to it. It's darkness does make her stand out though.

Nattie- I'm just not feeling this picture, looks like she just farted and she checking to see if anyone heard or smelt it.

Eve- Once again, another GREAT picture, I seriously think you're going to make it to the final two, might even win it.

Melina- I like it.

Alicia- Nice Pic! But it looks kind of cheap! Like it was filmed in a friends backyard.

Challenge #6 Photos

Sable: wow u really know how to put an age on how old sable is. mom hot pants? when did they come up with those. fail. 0

maryse: almost blended into the wall. wtf is the chair about to break for her to be holding on for dear life? not a fan of the outfit either, the shoes will make it a 2/10

Layla: someone already gave her a black eye? minus the makeup a good photo. 7/10

asian chick: wow those eyes fucked me up. whats wrong with them? why is she also trying to wear a picnic cloth on her tits? 0

Mickie: to many dots, and the pose not a fan. id like the bra and shorts if they went with something a bit more simple but together they mesh. 3/10

Alicia: nice rockstar look but the way shes standing make her look disformed in the ab area. and not a fan of the necklace with the look. 5/10

Beth: love everything but the lips. a bit of a darker shade would of made it better. 8/10

Eve: smiles kinda scary, 7/10

Sable- Pony Tail nice. Attire not so nice tho. Old picture.

Maryse- Cute Picture. She looks just like a preppy high school girl in this picture.

Layla- Cute picture with the whole boxer look. Nice pig tails.

Savannah- Who ever took this photo was a bad photographer. Her eyes in this picture are really weird. And there is a weird shadow over her chest that ruins the picture as well.

Mickie- Cute braider pig tails. I like the attire and the hat goes nice with it.

Alicia- I really don't care for this picture. You can't really see her hair or her eyes.

Beth- Really nice picture. One of the best for this challenge. I love how the butterfly makes this photo look.

Eve- One of the other best photos of this challenge. The low pig tails look nice.

Melina- Loving the side pony tail in this picture. This is also a great picture.

Nattie- Can't really see her hair. But I can tell it is up and not down.
I like the picture itself but im not really feeling the outfit.

Sable- It maybe a little dated, but I love it! The hot pants maybe a little high, but she still looks great, and the ponytail is must certainly there.

Maryse- Something about this photo, just isn't working for me, she looks like a pregnant chick trying a little to hard to be cute.

Layla- My second favorite picture of the week, she rocked it!!!

Savannah- I don't like this one at all, she's a very beautiful chick, but this picture doesn't show that at all, looks like she has a lazy eye, and it just won't stay open, and it looks like her face was smashed in with a shovel, this photo just isn't working for her.

Mickie- I like the girlie charm of the picture.

Alicia- I like the concept more then I like what I'm seeing, only thing that really stands out is her mouth, and it looks a little weird.

Beth- Best photo of the week to me, everything in this picture is working.

Eve- It's an ok photo, but definitely not one of her best, after seeing all her other pictures this one is kind of a let down.

Melina- *growls* I love this photo, she looks like a loin tamer and I'd must certainly let her tame me lol.

Nattie- This Picture is HOT! I love it.

Challenge #7

Sable- This is her one of her best pictures so far, but I think she may be a little too old to be playing Dorothy. Anyway it's a cutes picture kinda plain, but it'll work I guess.

Maryse- It's a nice picture, the outfit is sexy, but there's something about the face thats throwing me off, she seems bored or disgusted.

Layla- This outfit makes her look more like a Stripper, than a cop, I keep waiting for some cheesy music to start playing so she can do her little dance routine, while strange men put dollars in her panties, her face is SEXY, that can't be denied but the outfit makes her look like a really cheap stripper/hooker..SORRY.

Natalya- Not her best photo, the outfit is bland, her face looks awkward, I don't like her hair, the color of it is nice, but this photo just isn't doing anything for me.

Mickie-She's a cute girl, but this photo is so plain, she just standing there, she's not really selling anything, it's like she just idly standing by waiting for the photographer to finish.

Beth- It's a seductive photo, but it looks the top of her head was chopped off, then stitched back together, also it looks like there's a bump or something on her left eye, and they tried to cover it up with make up.

Eve- wow! This is NOT one of her best pictures, looks like she's trying to suck in her stomach so she can button up that top, and her hair looks like it's about to attack the right side of her face.

Alicia- She looks like an angry amputee, and isn't she breaking the "Avoid The Sunlight" rule???, it's a decent picture, but it most certainly could have been better.

Melina- Is she farting out a flag?!?!?!?! I like the pose and the boots, her eyes are creeping me out though, something about them just isn't working for me.

Sable: dress makes her look fat, she could of used a real dog too. 3/10

Maryse: lol how fake is that hair. i really want to focus on the rest of the outfit but it distracts me. 4/10

Layla: not a fan of the whip, and the top and bottom dont look like they match 6/10

Nattie: it could of been a bit sexier. a bit simple as well, 5/10

mickie: more fake hair? i hate the hair, im not a bit lory fan. eh 5/10

Beth: it looks like ur eating a burger or ur hair. 8/10

Eve: the hair a bit messed up and the boots are not to my liking. 7/10

Alicia: the hair, it would of been better if it was straight. the cape looks cheap too. 6/10

Melina: the bang looks like she has a really long side burn. 7/10

Sable: She does look old in this picture. Kinda like a soccor mom dressing up to go treak or treating with her kid. Dorthyis not for her.

Maryse: Love the french maid costume. Her hair is ok. And I agree with Tank there is something weird about her face. But I think its her lips.

Layla: Love the Layla cop costume. I think its a great costume for her.

Nattie: This cop picture im not feeling. I can't really tell its a costume (except with the hand cuffs). I don't like her hair either.

Mickie: I really like this outfit. I think she makes a great Tomb Raider.

Beth: She really looks like she can belong in the WNBA.

Eve: I think this is a great flawless picture of Eve. One of the best this week.

Alicia: Im not feeling the vampire thing. The setting should have been night.

Melina: The other best picture this challenge imo. The costume and hair looks great.

Challenge #8 Pictures

we should still do it

Do it then. Post your comments and send me your bottom 3. My comments wont be up tonight tho.

Maryse: why do one of her boobs look like a damn block? and not a fan of the weird half crawl thing. 3/10

Mickie: 2 things make this photo bad, 1st the suspenders. 2nd the photo was taken at a bad angle making her chin stand out more. 6/10

Alicia: not a fan of any of it, the pose is odd. the outfit doesnt look good, theres nothing to have this train wreck, not even trying to make it look pretty. 0

layla: oddly shaped boobs, bad smirk and that hair. oh no. 2/10

Eve: wtf is wrong with her eye. 7/10

Melina: looks like so kinda bondage type freaky shit going on. 5/10

Beth: has usual beth looks the best. sorta girl next door in this one but a lot more sexier. 10

sidenote: not a fan of the effects, just cause the pic is bad doesnt mean u can try to make it better cause tbh it kinda sucks.

Maryse: Love this picture!

Mickie: Also a great picture!

Alicia: Im not a fan of this picture either. The wings ruin it. And what she's wearing kinda looks fake to me.

Layla: Its a nice picture, but there is something a little off about it. I think its the smirk on her face.

Eve: Also a really nice picture. The dress, the pose, and i love how her hair looks like its flowing with the wind.

Melina: Cute pose and attire.

Beth: I like the dress and all. But the blue seat shes sitting one ruins the picture for me.

Maryse: EWWW!! Her face looks a mess, something about it is just wrong.

Mickie: It's ok

Alicia: Sorry, I just don't like it.

layla: nice!, but the face looks a little off.

Eve: You never disappoint! except for that one time lol.

Melina: I love it!

Beth: HOT! I LOVE IT!!!!!! Best photo of the week.

Beth: not a fan of the skirt. would have been much cuter with just the top. plus it looks airbrushed. 6/10
Melina: looks evil and not a cute evil, like a cruela devil wanna be. all shes missing is the puppys. 3/10
Maryse: sadly the best pic ive seen of her. she looks a lot better from a far. 8/10
Mickie: doesnt help that i dont find her attractive. somethings wrong with her face in this one though. 5/10
Layla: thats an awkward pose and that background. cant get over how miss shaped she looks. 0

Challenge #9 Photos

Maryse - I'm not really feeling this pic.
Mickie - The BEST picture of the week to me
Layla - Cute pic!, I most certainly kick her out, if she was in my room.
Melina - I love this picture, I'd most certainly like to unwrap her.
Beth - Everything looks good but the head, her faces looks weird.

Maryse: Not a fan of this picture. The whole outfit just doesn't look right to me.
Mickie: Nice sexy picture. Her face just looks really fake in the picture.
Layla: This picture does look a little awkward.
Melina: The best picture of this challenge imo. Love the attire and the background. Her hair looks really cute too.
Beth: This is a cute seductive picture.

Challenge 10 Comments

Maryse: Best Maryse picture we have seen thus far! And just like everyone else, I do love the skull pants lol.
Beth: Love the rose as the prop. Not a fan of her facial expression in this pic, but I do like the hair.
Melina: Nice sexy pose, and cute little attire.

Maryse: DAMN! Is that really Maryse?!?!?! What happened?? Why does she look real like a real person now?? I LOVE THIS PICTURE!

Beth: I like the black & white photo effect, but her face could have been a little better, it looks a little too tense.

Melina: That outift is SEXY!!, I most certainly wouldn't kick her out of my hotel room, The lighting and the furniture really help too, I like the entire photo, it's just all working well together.