Honestly, Who Do You Think Overall Is Better?

Who's the overall better package and would be remembered more?

I think Mickie James would be remembered more by the casual fan if I‘m being honest, there isn't much to remember about Melina other then her entrance, IMO. It’s no way a dig towards Melina at all but if most of us ask WWE fans “Hey do you like Melina?” 9 times out of 10, their response would be “Is that the girl that does the split leg entrance? Hell Yea I “like” Melina”

Wrestling:
Melina has a decent move-set but she just moves to quick, its like slow down women. Sometimes it comes off as sloppy and that makes me lose interest in her. I guess you can put some blame on her opponents but they don’t deserve full flame. Mickie James right now is just a repetitive, watered down, limited wrestler. Nothing new coming out of Mickie James for a long time. So i can't comment on her wrestling..

Promos:
Both are strong actresses so I don’t know who wins but I guess If I had to choose, Mickie would win for her “Ashley in the box” segment.

Anyways, discuss!

Mickie will always be remembered, she is gonna be in the class of the Litas and Trishes, not as big in a way, but still, she is gonna be remembered, she was around in those days, and had some great matches, i swear she got one of the biggest reactions at WM 22 out of all the matches, and this is a diva in WM
Melina will be remembered firstly for her entrance, and i agree the chick needs to slow down, theres a reason most of the matches she is in are sloppy, but because there are a lot of Melina marks on the net, they always flip it on the opponent, and use the excuse of them being "model turned diva", which aint fair at the most of times, a lot of the models now can hold themselves reasonable well like Alicia, Layla, Maryse, Eve, Kelly etc, yet when someone is doing shit too qucikly it aint a surprise that less expereinced girls arent going to catch on as quick

Mickie>Melina

well lets break it down

Mickie Pyscho>Mickie SD>Melina MnM>Melina Raw Heel>Mickie Raw face>Melina SD Face>Melina Raw face

Mickie is definitely the most over diva but you can't shut Melina out as she's been getting some good reactions as of late.

Mickie's moveset consists of the same shit over and over while Melina's moveset is unique and she comes up with something different in mostly every match. Melina hasn't had any problems with any of the divas like Michelle and Beth who can keep up with her moves and she still has had good matches with Alicia and Layla. The only good match Mickie has had recently is her TLC match with Michelle, I don't know what's up with her but she's just not the same anymore

As for mic skills, definitely Mickie but Melina isn't bad either

I think they will both be remembered for being great divas, Mickie as a psycho and Melina as a heel and her face moveset

Promo's? Diffrence is Mickie has never bombed in a segment. Melina on the other hand? She has bombed loads and loads of time in segments. She is not versitle and convincing, mickie on the other hand is.

Melina is a mediocre wrestler who gets way to many praises. You can ask her yourself, she truly believes she's gods gift to wrestling. Her set ups of her moves are horrible, they look like a choreographed movie dance sequens 50% of the time and the other 50% are stolen moves. Her style is soooo stolen and it's sad because despite stealing half her moves she manages to underperform them.