Is Melina The Greatest Heel Diva Of All Time?

Subject: Is Melina The Greatest Heel Diva Of All Time? Sat 05 Nov 2011, 9:22 pm

I gotta admit Melina has played one hell of a heel bitchy diva.And tba I think she was a better heel than stephanie mcmahon.Melina back on smackdown back when she was with MNM was pure awesome and many of her feuds like jillian,christy,trish and her greatest feud of all time Mickie James.She is by far one the greatest heels of all time.

the greatest heel diva of all time will be Vickie Guerrero, because the heat she gets is legit heat, not storyline heat.

i'd say Stephanie was better. Melina was an awesome heel but Stephanie just got so much more heat and she was so strong on the mic. Melina could sometimes overdo it but Stephanie was more natural. Melina was a better face because she got reactions hardly any other divas could get. she was nearly as over as Mickie

stephanie and vickie. Melina was good, but Lita too, espeiclay when she was with edge.

Vickie and Stephanie probably best overall but they are not really wrestlers so Lita, Melina, Trish, and Victoria probably got the most heat for wrestling women.

World Champion Number of posts : 1445 Registration date : 2011-06-10

There's a lot of competition for Melina. There's Moolah and Sherri in the Rock'n'Wrestling years. Luna Vachon in the 90s. Victoria & Psycho Mickie. And, of course, Trish, who I'd give the edge to. That 2004-05 run defined how to play the heel Champion.

well really Mickie was an awful heel since she never got booed if you think about it

No Melina was a good heel and had a lot of unique traits. I think to be a truly great heel or face, you have to be unique as well as have some memorable feuds. I don't think any of Melinas feuds as a heel were particularly epic . Off the top of my head I'd put

Stephanie McMahon - one of my favourite heels ever
Trish Stratus
Lita
Victoria
Mickie
Ivory - RTC
Sensational Sherri
Vickie Guerrero

All above Melina in terms of heel power. Even Jazz as well actually.

ricky_says_hi wrote:: well really Mickie was an awful heel since she never got booed if you think about it

Mickie was so good fans just loved her regardless. The reaction she got at WM 22 unreal.

In theory, I can definitely see your point as heels are supposed to be booed.

Think the short skirts and lesbian aspect of the storyline helped her popularity! I think the difficulty with most heels is that it's difficult to sustain a long run as a hated heel be aide if you're really good in any role, people do tend to start cheering for you regardless.

No, I think she was a really good heel, but not the best. I think Sensational Sherri, Luna Vachon, Judy Martin, and Moolah, were MUCH better heels. I think

World Champion Number of posts : 1445 Registration date : 2011-06-10

Chloe wrote:: Think the short skirts and lesbian aspect of the storyline helped her popularity! I think the difficulty with most heels is that it's difficult to sustain a long run as a hated heel be aide if you're really good in any role, people do tend to start cheering for you regardless.

Yeah, the short skirts and HLA got her lots of cheers. It depended on the audience. Some crowds would boo her, some cheered her because they loved her work. Same with Trish during her classic heel run.

I'd forgotten RTC Ivory in my earlier post. She's definately up there.

No doubt that helped. No doubt! lol

Aside from her attractiveness, she was hella crazy and fucking hilarious. Looney bin to say the least!

Other than Judy Martin who I'm not really familiar with, I've gotta agree with Scott.

» How Will Melina Be As A Heel This Time?
» Melina Heel Turn
» WD Top 20 Greatest Diva Matches Of All Time
» I miss Melina as a heel
» New Look for Heel Melina...?