Number of posts : 2062 Location : Heart of the City. (Ain't no love.) Job/hobbies : At home, drawing pictures of mountain tops. Favorite WWE Wrestler : CM Punk, Daniel Bryan, Santino Marella, The Shield. Favorite WWE Diva : AJ, Summer Rae, Rosa Mendes, Paige. Favorite TNA Wrestler : AJ Styles, Christopher Daniels, Samoa Joe, TJ Perkins. Favorite TNA Knockout : Taryn Terrell, Velvet Sky, Brooke Tessmacher, Christy Hemme. Registration date : 2010-12-23
Subject: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sat 25 Feb 2012, 3:37 am
(Note: I thought it'd be cool to start a discussion not based off of a game or WSHH video, lol.)
Wrestling has had plenty of great gimmicks, but for every Undertaker there are a thousand Battle Kats. Gimmicks can fail for a plethora of reasons, whether it be the performer not living up the gimmick, the company not marketing the performer, the gimmick not getting over, or the gimmick just being straight up terrible. No matter the reason, there has to be at least one that you enjoyed for it being awesome, terrible, terribly awesome, or awesomely terrible.
One of my favorite failed gimmicks is:
Repo Man
First off, Anyone who carries a rim to the ring has to be awesome. His mannerisms were always sneaky and shady, and while pretty much a joke, I thought it had plenty of potential. When the U.S. was recently in really bad shape economy wise, I thought the gimmick could have made a return with people not being able to pay for their possessions, etc.
I was originally going to post more, but I'm too tired atm... So what was your favorite train wreck?
KTV-Time WD Stalker
Number of posts : 14546 Age : 36 Location : The Netherlands, Europe Favorite WWE Wrestler : Dolph Ziggler
Tyson Kidd
Richie Steamboat
Brett & Ted Dibiasi
John Morrison
Heath Slater
Daniel Bryan
Justin Gabriel Favorite WWE Diva : Beth Phoenix
Natalya
Maryse
Alicia Fox
Eve Torres
Favorite TNA Wrestler : AJ Styles
Kaz
Amazing Red
Chris Sabin
Alex Shelly
Daniels
Eric Young
Orlando Jordan's Boy Toy Favorite TNA Knockout : Sarita
Angelina Love
Taylor Wilde
Santana G.
Registration date : 2009-06-13
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sat 25 Feb 2012, 6:58 am
DJ Gabriel and Alicia Fox.
The duo were fun, enjoyable and made me laugh whenever they made their way to the ring.
X Ultimate Opportunist
Number of posts : 8594 Age : 33 Location : Australia Favorite WWE Wrestler : ---
Justin Gabriel
Kofi Kingston
Chris Jericho
Tyson Kidd Favorite WWE Diva : ---
AJ
Kaitlyn
Natalya
Favorite TNA Wrestler : ---
Rob Van Dam
Favorite TNA Knockout : ---
Tara
Christy Hemme
Gail Registration date : 2008-08-24
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sat 25 Feb 2012, 8:55 am
Kevin Thorn Mordecai Kizarny Muhammad Hassan Eric Escobar Goldust
The Sexy Vixen Billion Dolla Princess
Number of posts : 28940 Age : 37 Location : The Negaverse, OH Job/hobbies : Daycare. I adore children. Favorite WWE Wrestler : Triple H, Orton, MVP, John Morrison, Dolph Ziggler, Kofi Kingston, Yoshi Tatsu, Zack Ryder Favorite WWE Diva : Stephanie McMahon, Maryse, Mickie James, Layla, Natalya, Beth, Michelle McCool, Katie Lea, Kelly Kelly, Nikki Bella, Rosa Mendes (Victoria and Lita are my all-time faves) Favorite TNA Wrestler : Jeff Jarrett, D'Angelo Dinero, MCMG, James Storm, AJ Styles, Amazing Red, Kiyoshi, Matt Morgan, Hernandez, Samoa Joe, Desmond Wolfe, Jeff Hardy, Kevin Nash Favorite TNA Knockout : ODB, Christy Hemme, Jacqueline, Tara, Hamada, Daffney, Lacey Von Erich, Registration date : 2009-03-23
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sat 25 Feb 2012, 11:10 am
Eric Escobar Just Joe
Paul Wyatt NCD aka Name Changing Dude
Number of posts : 18569 Age : 37 Location : Inside of my own mind Job/hobbies : Self-Improving Favorite WWE Wrestler : Antonio Cesaro
Bray Wyatt
Daniel Bryan
Dolph Ziggler
Sheamus
The Shield
The Usos
Wade Barrett Favorite WWE Diva : Naomi
Natalya Favorite TNA Wrestler : Austin Aries
Bobby Roode
Bully Ray
Eric Young
James Storm Registration date : 2008-07-31
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sat 25 Feb 2012, 1:03 pm
It Begins wrote:
Kevin Thorn Muhammad Hassan
These and:
Reflection of Perfection Mark Jinjrak Rob Conway (Just look at me) Rene Dupree Edge's debut gimmick. Chuck Palumbo's biker gimmick.
#WeWantTaryn Divas Lover.
Number of posts : 7477 Age : 32 Location : Providence,Rhode Island Favorite WWE Wrestler : Roman Reigns
Daniel Bryan
Jimmy & Jey Uso
Seth Rollins
Dolph Ziggler
Antonio Cesaro
Favorite WWE Diva : AJ Lee
Alicia Fox
Favorite TNA Wrestler : EC3
Austin Aries
MVP
Roode
Bobby Lashley
Kenny King Favorite TNA Knockout : Taryn Terrell
Brittany
Angelina Love Registration date : 2008-06-28
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sat 25 Feb 2012, 2:32 pm
Natayla Farting Santino Marella Hornswoggle(I hate that lil guy) That dude from tna who made that one apperence on ecw then got released. Kelly Kelly Stripper John Cena Dr.Thuganomics
Serial World Champion
Number of posts : 2062 Location : Heart of the City. (Ain't no love.) Job/hobbies : At home, drawing pictures of mountain tops. Favorite WWE Wrestler : CM Punk, Daniel Bryan, Santino Marella, The Shield. Favorite WWE Diva : AJ, Summer Rae, Rosa Mendes, Paige. Favorite TNA Wrestler : AJ Styles, Christopher Daniels, Samoa Joe, TJ Perkins. Favorite TNA Knockout : Taryn Terrell, Velvet Sky, Brooke Tessmacher, Christy Hemme. Registration date : 2010-12-23
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sat 25 Feb 2012, 3:27 pm
I don't know if Santino is a failure, since he's done pretty well as of late and has had a nice run in the WWE.
DrizzyDrakeFan wrote:
That dude from tna who made that one apperence on ecw then got released.
Vance Archer? Cassidy Riley? Marcus Cor Von? Braden Walker?
#WeWantTaryn Divas Lover.
Number of posts : 7477 Age : 32 Location : Providence,Rhode Island Favorite WWE Wrestler : Roman Reigns
Daniel Bryan
Jimmy & Jey Uso
Seth Rollins
Dolph Ziggler
Antonio Cesaro
Favorite WWE Diva : AJ Lee
Alicia Fox
Favorite TNA Wrestler : EC3
Austin Aries
MVP
Roode
Bobby Lashley
Kenny King Favorite TNA Knockout : Taryn Terrell
Brittany
Angelina Love Registration date : 2008-06-28
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sat 25 Feb 2012, 3:35 pm
Brandon walker
Eric Hall Of Famer
Number of posts : 6318 Age : 32 Favorite WWE Diva : Top 5
(Including NXT)
#1 - Nikki Bella
#2 - Charlotte
#3 - Summer Rae
#4 - Eva Marie
#5 - Alicia Fox Favorite TNA Knockout : Top 5
#1 - Brooke
#2 - Taryn Terrell
#3 - Angelina Love
#4 - Brittany
#5 - Gail Kim Registration date : 2008-11-15
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sat 25 Feb 2012, 3:36 pm
DrizzyDrakeFan wrote:
Natayla Farting
Dude her name is Natalya.
Even in your "favorite WWE Divas" section, you wrote Natayla. :/
Serial World Champion
Number of posts : 2062 Location : Heart of the City. (Ain't no love.) Job/hobbies : At home, drawing pictures of mountain tops. Favorite WWE Wrestler : CM Punk, Daniel Bryan, Santino Marella, The Shield. Favorite WWE Diva : AJ, Summer Rae, Rosa Mendes, Paige. Favorite TNA Wrestler : AJ Styles, Christopher Daniels, Samoa Joe, TJ Perkins. Favorite TNA Knockout : Taryn Terrell, Velvet Sky, Brooke Tessmacher, Christy Hemme. Registration date : 2010-12-23
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sat 25 Feb 2012, 3:52 pm
Maybe he rushed and accidentally typo'd?
"Brandon Walker" when his ring name was "Braden Walker" is complete ignorance though.
#WeWantTaryn Divas Lover.
Number of posts : 7477 Age : 32 Location : Providence,Rhode Island Favorite WWE Wrestler : Roman Reigns
Daniel Bryan
Jimmy & Jey Uso
Seth Rollins
Dolph Ziggler
Antonio Cesaro
Favorite WWE Diva : AJ Lee
Alicia Fox
Favorite TNA Wrestler : EC3
Austin Aries
MVP
Roode
Bobby Lashley
Kenny King Favorite TNA Knockout : Taryn Terrell
Brittany
Angelina Love Registration date : 2008-06-28
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sat 25 Feb 2012, 4:15 pm
Does it matter how I spell someone's name as long as you know who I'm talking about then it should be ok with you.
Serial World Champion
Number of posts : 2062 Location : Heart of the City. (Ain't no love.) Job/hobbies : At home, drawing pictures of mountain tops. Favorite WWE Wrestler : CM Punk, Daniel Bryan, Santino Marella, The Shield. Favorite WWE Diva : AJ, Summer Rae, Rosa Mendes, Paige. Favorite TNA Wrestler : AJ Styles, Christopher Daniels, Samoa Joe, TJ Perkins. Favorite TNA Knockout : Taryn Terrell, Velvet Sky, Brooke Tessmacher, Christy Hemme. Registration date : 2010-12-23
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sat 25 Feb 2012, 4:32 pm
Wlel in taht csae I'll jsut tpye lkie tihs teh whloe tmie snice you'll konw waht I'm tlaknig abuot.
Saen O' Harie's divel's adovacte was a graet gimmikc.
#WeWantTaryn Divas Lover.
Number of posts : 7477 Age : 32 Location : Providence,Rhode Island Favorite WWE Wrestler : Roman Reigns
Daniel Bryan
Jimmy & Jey Uso
Seth Rollins
Dolph Ziggler
Antonio Cesaro
Favorite WWE Diva : AJ Lee
Alicia Fox
Favorite TNA Wrestler : EC3
Austin Aries
MVP
Roode
Bobby Lashley
Kenny King Favorite TNA Knockout : Taryn Terrell
Brittany
Angelina Love Registration date : 2008-06-28
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sat 25 Feb 2012, 5:11 pm
Stop it that's not what I ment you know my spelling isn't good and I didn't mean it like the way your typeing
Serial World Champion
Number of posts : 2062 Location : Heart of the City. (Ain't no love.) Job/hobbies : At home, drawing pictures of mountain tops. Favorite WWE Wrestler : CM Punk, Daniel Bryan, Santino Marella, The Shield. Favorite WWE Diva : AJ, Summer Rae, Rosa Mendes, Paige. Favorite TNA Wrestler : AJ Styles, Christopher Daniels, Samoa Joe, TJ Perkins. Favorite TNA Knockout : Taryn Terrell, Velvet Sky, Brooke Tessmacher, Christy Hemme. Registration date : 2010-12-23
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sat 25 Feb 2012, 5:16 pm
I'm just joshing with you, DL. Chill out, it's all good, lol.
#WeWantTaryn Divas Lover.
Number of posts : 7477 Age : 32 Location : Providence,Rhode Island Favorite WWE Wrestler : Roman Reigns
Daniel Bryan
Jimmy & Jey Uso
Seth Rollins
Dolph Ziggler
Antonio Cesaro
Favorite WWE Diva : AJ Lee
Alicia Fox
Favorite TNA Wrestler : EC3
Austin Aries
MVP
Roode
Bobby Lashley
Kenny King Favorite TNA Knockout : Taryn Terrell
Brittany
Angelina Love Registration date : 2008-06-28
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sat 25 Feb 2012, 5:23 pm
I'm not mad I just dont care
Dead The Sports Guy
Number of posts : 31046 Age : 39 Location : Maryland Registration date : 2008-08-19
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sat 25 Feb 2012, 5:28 pm
It Begins wrote:
Kevin Thorn Mordecai Kizarny Muhammad Hassan Eric Escobar Goldust
Muhammad Hassan wasnt a failed gimmick, not in the slightest
my list includes Mordecai The Boogeyman Glacier Rellik
Paul Wyatt NCD aka Name Changing Dude
Number of posts : 18569 Age : 37 Location : Inside of my own mind Job/hobbies : Self-Improving Favorite WWE Wrestler : Antonio Cesaro
Bray Wyatt
Daniel Bryan
Dolph Ziggler
Sheamus
The Shield
The Usos
Wade Barrett Favorite WWE Diva : Naomi
Natalya Favorite TNA Wrestler : Austin Aries
Bobby Roode
Bully Ray
Eric Young
James Storm Registration date : 2008-07-31
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sat 25 Feb 2012, 5:51 pm
It wasn't a fail per se, but the controversial nature of it was. Sucks that he had to be written off of the program, but it is what it is.
KTV-Time WD Stalker
Number of posts : 14546 Age : 36 Location : The Netherlands, Europe Favorite WWE Wrestler : Dolph Ziggler
Tyson Kidd
Richie Steamboat
Brett & Ted Dibiasi
John Morrison
Heath Slater
Daniel Bryan
Justin Gabriel Favorite WWE Diva : Beth Phoenix
Natalya
Maryse
Alicia Fox
Eve Torres
Favorite TNA Wrestler : AJ Styles
Kaz
Amazing Red
Chris Sabin
Alex Shelly
Daniels
Eric Young
Orlando Jordan's Boy Toy Favorite TNA Knockout : Sarita
Angelina Love
Taylor Wilde
Santana G.
Registration date : 2009-06-13
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sat 25 Feb 2012, 6:16 pm
It Begins wrote:
Kevin Thorn Mordecai
Weren't they portrayed by the same Person?
The Dudebusters as well loved them!!!
and in memory of my fave!!
Did You Miss Her? Hall Of Famer
Number of posts : 9685 Age : 36 Location : Xavier's School Is Where I'm Laying My Head! Job/hobbies : Stroking Zachary Quinto's Ego.... Favorite WWE Wrestler : Dolph Ziggler, Kofi Kingston, John Morrison, Santino, Edge, Christian, Cody Rhodes, Randy Orton, Sheamus, & CM Punk. Favorite WWE Diva : Melina, Beth Phoenix, Layla, Alicia Fox, & Gail Kim. Favorite TNA Wrestler : Daniels, MCMGs, Crimson, Amazing Redd, Eric Young, Matt Morgan, Kurt Angle, & Generation Me. Favorite TNA Knockout : Winter, Brooke Tessmacher, Mickie James, Madison Rayne, & Angelina Love. Registration date : 2008-07-27
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sun 26 Feb 2012, 11:25 am
Glacier
I thought he was awesome, especially in WCW vs NWO Revenge for the N64, whenever you got a finisher with him you could that 10 hit combo, oh I loved that.
3-Count
They were a little douchy, but I loved them and I thoght that verta-breaker was sick!
Jung Dragons
I thought Leia Meow was HOT!
Eric Hall Of Famer
Number of posts : 6318 Age : 32 Favorite WWE Diva : Top 5
(Including NXT)
#1 - Nikki Bella
#2 - Charlotte
#3 - Summer Rae
#4 - Eva Marie
#5 - Alicia Fox Favorite TNA Knockout : Top 5
#1 - Brooke
#2 - Taryn Terrell
#3 - Angelina Love
#4 - Brittany
#5 - Gail Kim Registration date : 2008-11-15
Subject: Re: Favorite Failed Gimmicks. Sun 26 Feb 2012, 2:12 pm
DrizzyDrakeFan wrote:
Does it matter how I spell someone's name as long as you know who I'm talking about then it should be ok with you.
You're talking to a future French/English teacher.
Yes, spelling matters to me. A lot.
WarGreymon77 Midcarder
Number of posts : 466 Age : 35 Location : South Hill, VA Favorite WWE Wrestler : The Undertaker, Triple H, R-Truth, Booker T, Teddy Long, CM Punk Favorite WWE Diva : 'Kharma', Kelly Kelly, Maryse Favorite TNA Wrestler : Sting, Brother Devon, A.J. Styles, Beer Money Inc, "The Pope" D'Angelo Dinero Favorite TNA Knockout : Velvet Sky, Mickie James, Angelina Love, So Cal Val, Daffney... Registration date : 2011-02-02
Get up on your feet! Put your hands together!! Sing along with 3 count We'll party on forever!!
we like the backstreet boys, nsync too britney spears is kinda cute we watch TRL on MTV everybody 3count...1! 2! 3!
1....2.....3!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Paul Wyatt NCD aka Name Changing Dude
Number of posts : 18569 Age : 37 Location : Inside of my own mind Job/hobbies : Self-Improving Favorite WWE Wrestler : Antonio Cesaro
Bray Wyatt
Daniel Bryan
Dolph Ziggler
Sheamus
The Shield
The Usos
Wade Barrett Favorite WWE Diva : Naomi
Natalya Favorite TNA Wrestler : Austin Aries
Bobby Roode
Bully Ray
Eric Young
James Storm Registration date : 2008-07-31
It was kinda cool in the beginning, but it became the largest pile of shit on the network.
WarGreymon77 Midcarder
Number of posts : 466 Age : 35 Location : South Hill, VA Favorite WWE Wrestler : The Undertaker, Triple H, R-Truth, Booker T, Teddy Long, CM Punk Favorite WWE Diva : 'Kharma', Kelly Kelly, Maryse Favorite TNA Wrestler : Sting, Brother Devon, A.J. Styles, Beer Money Inc, "The Pope" D'Angelo Dinero Favorite TNA Knockout : Velvet Sky, Mickie James, Angelina Love, So Cal Val, Daffney... Registration date : 2011-02-02
I have Fuse but they even dont play music like they used to.
#WeWantTaryn Divas Lover.
Number of posts : 7477 Age : 32 Location : Providence,Rhode Island Favorite WWE Wrestler : Roman Reigns
Daniel Bryan
Jimmy & Jey Uso
Seth Rollins
Dolph Ziggler
Antonio Cesaro
Favorite WWE Diva : AJ Lee
Alicia Fox
Favorite TNA Wrestler : EC3
Austin Aries
MVP
Roode
Bobby Lashley
Kenny King Favorite TNA Knockout : Taryn Terrell
Brittany
Angelina Love Registration date : 2008-06-28