Mickie vs Melina

who is the better all around performer? Friendly debate, guys....which means no flaming or else i'll be handing out warnings. So, please be civilized.

and i'll save you the trouble, Dead: "They both suck"

aww, well arent you just the sweetest....lol

Well, though I hate the divas too Dead, you must admit these two or the better overall performers in the Divas Division.

I'm gonna have to go with Mickie here. She's got more wrestling skill and entertainment value than Melina does.

Before I answer the question, I want to know what's your definition of 'overall performer,' Vix?

Overall performer.. from what I'm guessing, meaning.. who has the best skills overall.. lol. That includes mic and ring skills, crowd reaction, and entertainment value.

Perhaps, but Divas are put on a different pedestal, so I want see how she defines best overall since this is her question.

Well, I was just saying the normal definition.. hoping to clear things up.

This was a hard one, both are great. But I have to go with Melina, lately I been seeing some new stuff with her and I havent really seen anything new with Mickie.

New and not new stuff doesn't make a difference on who's the better all around performer.

Hands down Mickie James, their shouldn't have been a comparison. Mickie is WAY above Melina in wrestling skills, Mickie is slightly over rated while Melina is VERY over rated as a wrestler. Mickie is very diverse, she could play face & Heel without a problem, i had issue's believing Melina was face.....she seems so fake.

Also Melina is such an awefull wrestler sometimes (well compared to how great her marks make herself and how great she herself thinks she is....she has such a huge ego). If the spotlight isn't on her or she's not the center of attention, she wrestles crap, Melina can't just go out and "Wrestle" because everytime she does their needs to be a storyline because her matches...well usuall tell some sort of Story. Mickie could just go out and wrestle her usual sluggish matches.

Yes i said Sluggish...which in reality is really her style. Muche like how lita had this sloppyness to her wrestling, Katie Lea has her akward way of wrestling and Melina's matches look as choreographed as a dance number.....Mickie has this sluggish style.....which doesn't bother me as much as Melina's wrestling.

I guess my choice is pretty obvious.

NCD Punk wrote:

Before I answer the question, I want to know what's your definition of 'overall performer,' Vix?

hell if I know

according to everyone I dont know shit about wrestling so i'm keeping my thoughts to myself.

'overall performer' means whatever you want it to mean.

Mickie is the total package Mickie can wrestle can talk on the mic and has carisma melina has worked on her ring skills but mickie is way out of her league

Mickie is boring, blah and acts like a retard with her bouncing and overall annoyance. She can't carry for shit, but she can at least look on par with stronger workers (Trish, Beth). She can be very sloppy in her deliverance of wrestling moves, but she's a good striker.

Melina is boring, blah and refuses to accept that people only care when her legs are open. Then again, when even her biggest fan is going on about how impossible it is to watch her now.. She can't carry for shit and a lot of times her matches have a "Well, only if I can win, then I will do my best!" feel to them. I know I would be fucking pissed if I had 2159763468 matches with Maria, but Melina did nothing her "veteran" or "good worker" reputation claims it is.

I went with Mickie. She's had more better than par matches than Melina.. Even though I think they are both terribly overrated.