Smackdown Vs RAW BATTLE! (Bracket 1)

I'm bored so I'll do a little contest, to see which brand is the overall best. Bracket one pits Beth Pheonix (Raw) against Michelle McCool (Smackdown)

Both are considered the top females of the WWE or top heels? Since they bulldoze through all the divas. Both have been called boring. I ask my members....


Who betta and why?

Beth can do convincing power moves.
Beth has no problem SELLING for weaker fores.
Beth has no problem JOBBING.
Beth knows when to be stiff and when to lighten the blows.
Beth's whole moveset makes sense! She ain't picking moves she thought were cool looking like when someone does the CAW in a video game.
Beth has in ring presence that doesn't come from her just being some big broad.

And if nothing else, Beth's character is an humanitarian. I mean, she is giving Rosa a chance while most everyone else wants that slut fired. When's the last time Michelle did something so nice to try and help get someone over?

sarcy wrote:

Beth can do convincing power moves.
Beth has no problem SELLING for weaker fores.
Beth has no problem JOBBING.
Beth knows when to be stiff and when to lighten the blows.
Beth's whole moveset makes sense! She ain't picking moves she thought were cool looking like when someone does the CAW in a video game.
Beth has in ring presence that doesn't come from her just being some big broad.

And if nothing else, Beth's character is an humanitarian. I mean, she is giving Rosa a chance while most everyone else wants that slut fired. When's the last time Michelle did something so nice to try and help get someone over?

I couldn't have said that any better myself.

Exactly.

lol at the person who voted mcnosell
although i dont really care lol shes ok ....ish......may......be....not

LL "THE GREAT" wrote:

lol at the person who voted mcnosell
although i dont really care lol shes ok ....ish......may......be....not

I bet Blue voted her, he "loves" her.

sarcy wrote:

Beth can do convincing power moves.
Beth has no problem SELLING for weaker fores.
Beth has no problem JOBBING.
Beth knows when to be stiff and when to lighten the blows.
Beth's whole moveset makes sense! She ain't picking moves she thought were cool looking like when someone does the CAW in a video game.
Beth has in ring presence that doesn't come from her just being some big broad.

And if nothing else, Beth's character is an humanitarian. I mean, she is giving Rosa a chance while most everyone else wants that slut fired. When's the last time Michelle did something so nice to try and help get someone over?

Michelle... you suck!

Someone needs to vote Michelle to get some type of debate going :speedy:

theres no real debate needed

sarcy wrote:

Beth can do convincing power moves.
Beth has no problem SELLING for weaker fores.
Beth has no problem JOBBING.
Beth knows when to be stiff and when to lighten the blows.
Beth's whole moveset makes sense! She ain't picking moves she thought were cool looking like when someone does the CAW in a video game.
Beth has in ring presence that doesn't come from her just being some big broad.

And if nothing else, Beth's character is an humanitarian. I mean, she is giving Rosa a chance while most everyone else wants that slut fired. When's the last time Michelle did something so nice to try and help get someone over?

I agree

We'd just call whoever voted Michelle a moron and there would be no interesting debate.

lol.

Well despite her lack of selling, I think Michelle is indeed a hard working woman... She busts her ass in every match and brings out the absolute best out of the lessar divas.. She carried Layla into a decent match early last year and really shined against Maryse. Maryse and Michelle were eachothers Ying to eachothers Yang, if that made sense. They just worked well together and since separting from McCool, Maryse has been exposed on Raw.

Michelle doesn't baby her opponents like Beth does...

Michelle has chemistry with Mickie James while Beth doesn't
Michelle and Melina are more exciting compared to Beth Vs Melina earlier this year.
Michelle has chemistry with Gail Kim and Maryse as well.

Beth is a great athelete, do not get me wrong but she has been boring to watch wrestle. Hopefully with Gail, we'll see a new side of her.

Baby? BABY? Beth knows that Mickie can take harder hits than Maria. That's not "babying". That's called being considerate. Wrestling is a rough sport and shit happens.. But it's also fake and there's no reason for the wrestlers to treat it like a shoot fight.

All of those things are opinion based.

Wait.. You just knocked other "top" divas in Mickie, Beth and Maryse just to make Michelle look better? Yeah, Michelle does the same thing. Damn ego.

I am not saying Michelle doesn't work hard. I am just saying I am sick of people putting her on a fucking pedestal. Out of all the SD chicks, she's been the ONLY one to have consistent matches in the past two years. In matches where SHE was the only one who got to showcase all of her offense while the other divas had to make her shit look God like. It's easy to make people think you are better than the people around you if YOU are the only one allowed to do anything. That and most wrestlers naturally get better with more experience and so far, Michelle has been the only DS chick currently to be treated as holier than thou.

Ladies and gentlemen, THAT is why I cannot stand Michelle.

ladies and gentlemen this is why sarcy is epic ^

sarcy wrote:

Baby? BABY? Beth knows that Mickie can take harder hits than Maria. That's not "babying". That's called being considerate. Wrestling is a rough sport and shit happens.. But it's also fake and there's no reason for the wrestlers to treat it like a shoot fight.

All of those things are opinion based.

Wait.. You just knocked other "top" divas in Mickie, Beth and Maryse just to make Michelle look better? Yeah, Michelle does the same thing. Damn ego.

I am not saying Michelle doesn't work hard. I am just saying I am sick of people putting her on a fucking pedestal. Out of all the SD chicks, she's been the ONLY one to have consistent matches in the past two years. In matches where SHE was the only one who got to showcase all of her offense while the other divas had to make her shit look God like. It's easy to make people think you are better than the people around you if YOU are the only one allowed to do anything. That and most wrestlers naturally get better with more experience and so far, Michelle has been the only DS chick currently to be treated as holier than thou.

Ladies and gentlemen, THAT is why I cannot stand Michelle.

Preach it Sarcy. People need to understand this.

sarcy wrote:

Baby? BABY? Beth knows that Mickie can take harder hits than Maria. That's not "babying". That's called being considerate. Wrestling is a rough sport and shit happens.. But it's also fake and there's no reason for the wrestlers to treat it like a shoot fight.

All of those things are opinion based.

Wait.. You just knocked other "top" divas in Mickie, Beth and Maryse just to make Michelle look better? Yeah, Michelle does the same thing. Damn ego.

I am not saying Michelle doesn't work hard. I am just saying I am sick of people putting her on a fucking pedestal. Out of all the SD chicks, she's been the ONLY one to have consistent matches in the past two years. In matches where SHE was the only one who got to showcase all of her offense while the other divas had to make her shit look God like. It's easy to make people think you are better than the people around you if YOU are the only one allowed to do anything. That and most wrestlers naturally get better with more experience and so far, Michelle has been the only DS chick currently to be treated as holier than thou.

Ladies and gentlemen, THAT is why I cannot stand Michelle.

Definately Beth, Sarcy nearly took the words out of my mouth with the reasoning, no reason to repeat it.

Defo Beth.

Sarcy said it all for me. And as far as babying oppoents its called being careful not to hurt someone. Wrestling isnt supposed to be some real fight. Its a staged fight.

Michelle is stiff but being stiff can cause injuries. LOL You are NOT supposed to be stiff.

Anyways Beth has worked hard too. She may not be the worlds greatest entertainer, but her wrestling speaks for itself. Its something unique.

So Beth > Michelle by a longshot.