SMACKDOWN VS RAW BATTLE! (Bracket 2)

This bracket pits Melina representing SD against Mickie James representing Raw. Melina is a 3 time Women's Champion while Mickie James is a 4 time Women's Champion as well as the current Divas Champion.

Some have compared these two to Trish Stratus and Lita basically because Melina and Mickie have feuded and have been allies just like Trish and Lita. I see the similarities.

But they are against eachother so who betta?

Uhm. Melina is on SD
And Mickie is on Raw. Little problem in the poll there.

I actually when with Melina. Both are pretty even at the "sub par" level for me..

But when Melina is getting pushed, she at least tries to have a fire under her ass. Mickie is always so unmotivated and condescending.

Hailey wrote:

Uhm. Melina is on SD
And Mickie is on Raw. Little problem in the poll there.

FIXED!

i will go with melina because currently over the past few months she has impressed me a bit more, shows more variety in her move set...and well doesnt really mess up her finisher, mickies ddt irritates me a lot

I'mma go with Mickie just cause she's the better performer overall - ring skills, mic skills all that stuff. Sure she's a bit sloppy, but I find that unique about her, since she still pulls off decent matches.

I'm going to have to say Melina because Melina has been on Raw and SD and has blazed up both brands as a heel and a face. Mickie is a four time women's champion and a one time Divas champion which is a great accomplishment but it's all been just on Raw as her WWE career has been on Raw so im going to say Melina since she has made a impact on Raw and SD brands.

Both of these women are extremely beautiful and talented women and are both a major asset to the company of WWE.

Both are good, but both don't try very hard. Melina tries the most out of two with a lack of effort. Both can be good when they try their hardest.

CWL91 wrote:

Both are good, but both don't try very hard. Melina tries the most out of two with a lack of effort. Both can be good when they try their hardest.

It's funny now that I think of my original response. Melina's wrestling really does come off as forced while Mickie's comes off as lazy.

Still, I think Melina thinks she has a chip on her shoulder. Shitty wrestler or not.

I will have to say Melina. Melina shows she can play a face and a heel. While Mickie isnt as good as a face. Both are great wrestlers with great movesets.

Melina has been getting more over and shes doing better. I prefer Melina to Mickie, but I love them both.

My vote goes to Mickie James,I can't stand Melina, the girl is HIGHLY over rated, she loves watching MsChiff matches because she uses half her moves on TV. And her wrestling is not as great a she makes it to be. If Melina didn't have such a big ego i'd vote for her. But since once apon a time she claimed Mickie "stole her style" and "copied her wrestling style" is just laughable. Melina isn't half the wrestler Mickie is but hey whatever.

Plus Melina is NOT and i repeat NOT a believable face. All her interviews since being a face has been HORIBLE tbh. Especially compared to her heel work. Plus her "innovation" she adds in her matches are crap most of the time. Her spilts are over used while her spots takes way to much to set up. Melina bores me most of the times because of her offence, they aren't creative just either stolen from someone else *cough MsCHiff Cough* or just extremly crap.