SMACKDOWN VS RAW BATTLE! (Bracket 3)

Bracket three pits Jillian Hall against Katie Lea Burchill... ECW travels with SD so I will use Kat for this round. Both are considered to be jobbers. Extremely underated and never really got there chance to shine especially Jillian.

But I ask you guys, who betta? Explain!

I went with Katie Lea on this one. Just cuz I wanna be alll rebelious and stand by the fact that I think Jillian's overratedness matches her physical grotesqueness.

i am going with katie because i think she is a more solid wrestler. and has a lot more promise in my eyes to be able to use her character and skill to get out of the rutt she is in

I'm going to go with Katie Lea on this one simply because she is the overall better wrestler. She's way more solid in the ring.

If only Katie wasn't on ECW, because if she was on Smackdown I'm sure she'd get more time to shine. ECW doesn't really show Women's matches and it's sad to see any divas stuck there.

Katie > Jillian.

Now granted Jillian has more charisma, but Katie has more going for her: she sells moves better, executes better - she's an overall more technical wrestler. Atm she's on tv doing something, wereas Jillian hasn't been seen in years.... there must be a reason for that!

Whoa im in the minority today for realz! I take it some ppl let Jillian's jobbing get to there head? Because the bitch can go in the ring... Infact I like Katie but she has yet to impress me, ppl say she's great but she didn't bring it against Mickie James last year, why else would WWE job her out?

Jillian makes the shittest of the shit look like a threat (Im looking at you Maria/Ashley and Kelly)

She sells there whack ass moves like death.

My favorite Jillian match was against Melina back in 2006. It was at Judgement Day. Katie's was at NOC last year against Mickie James and even that wasn't that great.

No one is saying she can't wrestle, Blue; we're just saying that Katie more technically sound.

The Family Guy wrote:

No one is saying she can't wrestle, Blue; we're just saying that Katie more technically sound.

Exactly.

As for Katie not delivering against Mickie, I don't know if it was just me, but I liked that match.

Katie Lea. She is by far the better wrestler, if you have compared them at their best in OVW. And Katie Lea actually looks attractive, unlike Jillian nowadays.

Hmm this is a hard one but I went with Katie. Shes just a little bit of a better wrestler and Jillian needs a gimmick change.

My votes goes to Jillian Hall, not putting down Katie Lea, but i've always had issue's with Katie's wrestling. I've never found any matches that she really meshed with her opponents. ODB, Beth & Mickie are probably the only people Katie worked good matches with. The rest were just weird. Katie has this akwardness about her wrestling. Especially her execusion of moves. Her selling isn't bad at all. But she moves around akwardly.

On the other hand, Jillian is one of the girls that could do it all, she could brawl, try a little high flying stuffs, get right down and technical, she can do it all. She's very similar to Molly Holly, someone esle who could do it all. There really hasn't been a match were i feel Jillian has dissapointed me, she works well with everyone and carried many girls through decent showings. Aside from Victoria, she carried many girls into higher a better feuds. Before going for Ashley, Kristal went through Jillian, before going to mania, Ashley went through Jillian, before becoming SD's nr. 1 diva, Michelle went through Jillian. And the list goes on.

Jillian gets my vote.