Beth Phoenix or Natalya Neidhart

Who do you think is the better wrestler? Just comparing wrestling skills.

I love both of them, but I think Beth is better.

Beth is definitely better

Better wrestler? Definitely Natalya. With a Hart Dungeon training behind you it's hard not to be better than most.

Beth is pushed better but ultimately I think Natalya is the better wrestler.

This is hard. I think both are equally as good. The difference is one has been pushed and the other one hasnt been pushed to her full potental yet.


Ill have to make my choice later. I dunno if I can vote in this poll.

it's just a comparison of who is better in the ring only..it doesnt matter who is getting pushed or not..just who has better ring skills.

I like Beth better I find Natayla boring

The Sexy Vixen wrote:

it's just a comparison of who is better in the ring only..it doesnt matter who is getting pushed or not..just who has better ring skills.

Thats why I cant choose. Both are equally good. Its that I wish Nat had the oppertunity to show what she can do.

The Sexy Vixen wrote:

it's just a comparison of who is better in the ring only..it doesnt matter who is getting pushed or not..just who has better ring skills.

This is why I voted Natalya. It seems people disagree with me though.

Beth pwns.

It's not even close. Beth botches and fucks up. Natayla has put on technical matches and shows great psychology and story telling ability every single time she works a match past 5 minutes. It's not fair to Beth to compare her to someone that good. Beth does formula matches where faces back down to her power wrestling spots while Natayla does all the sneaky heel shit that is excellent to watch if you're a true wrestling fan. Natayla vs Mickie on Smackdown damn near blew away all of those botched Beth/Mickie matches of the last two years.

I like them both immensely. Therefore I won't vote because I cannot vote for both of them.

VLG. wrote:

The Sexy Vixen wrote:

it's just a comparison of who is better in the ring only..it doesnt matter who is getting pushed or not..just who has better ring skills.

This is why I voted Natalya. It seems people disagree with me though.

I agree with you.

Pretty torn here! Though I don't think Beth botches or fucks up like Laylamark said But I do notice that Beth/Mickie matches are snoozeville most of the time where I was pretty entertained by Mickie/Natalya

However Beth/Michelle matches >>>>>> Nattie/Michelle

Natalya/Kelly matches >>>>>>>> Kelly/Beth matches


It's a friggin toss up but I'll give Natalya the edge here (barely)

Beth and Mickie have had some pretty good matches, Mickie and Nattie was just decent.

Queen Blue wrote:

Pretty torn here! Though I don't think Beth botches or fucks up like Laylamark said But I do notice that Beth/Mickie matches are snoozeville most of the time where I was pretty entertained by Mickie/Natalya

However Beth/Michelle matches >>>>>> Nattie/Michelle

Natalya/Kelly matches >>>>>>>> Kelly/Beth matches


It's a friggin toss up but I'll give Natalya the edge here (barely)

wow Blue.

looks like you pulled out a pen and paper and did some hardcore analyzing for this topic lol

This is really hard. Because these women look soo much alike but when it comes to wrestling they are sooooo diffrent and offer two complete diffrent styles to the table.

Natlaya is just brutal, she is rough, hard hitting, she could make simple moves like Suplexes, Bodyslams, simple kicks look vicious. It's her vicious style. She isn't as technically round like Beth Phoenix, but she isn't that far either.

Beth on the other hand is pure power and being technical. She is technically smooth. But manages to pull out power house moves and make them look good. She can't make a suplex or body slams look good. But she has the extra added power factor and has a more intimidating feel to her when you watch her wrestle.

This is a real toss up and at this point can't really vote. These two bring two complete diffrent styles to the table so might have to think it through a little more.

BETH

After thinking it through i ended up with best. She is just slightly more versetile then Natalya...by just a tiny margin

well...i will admitt i voted before reading the message
i thought it was a "WHO you prefer" things...and Beth pwns Nattie in that

as far as wrestling skill.....i dont see Nattie wrestle a great deal
and ppl tend to over hype shit like the hart dungeon

so i dunno, i woulda prolly voted Beth regardless

Pretty much LL, I like Nattie but people do overrate her a bit because she's a Hart

CWL91 wrote:

I like them both immensely. Therefore I won't vote because I cannot vote for both of them.

Going back to my vote yesterday, since Nattie's arrival in the WWE I've liked her a tad bit more; but, it was a tough vote for me though. I can understand where you're coming from, they're both so talented.