Mickie James or Melina Perez??

Subject: Mickie James or Melina Perez?? Wed 12 Oct 2011, 10:41 pm

Better Ring Entrence?
Better Theme Music?
Better Ring Attire?
Better Face?
Better Heel?
Better Champion?
Better Wrestler?

Subject: Re: Mickie James or Melina Perez?? Wed 12 Oct 2011, 10:59 pm

Better Ring Entrence? Mickie
Better Theme Music? Mickie
Better Ring Attire? Melina
Better Face? Mickie
Better Heel? Melina
Better Champion? Mickie
Better Wrestler? Mickie

Final Score: Mickie - 5 Melina - 2

Winner: Mickie

Subject: Re: Mickie James or Melina Perez?? Thu 13 Oct 2011, 1:09 am

Anti Melina till the day i die

Mickie wins hands down

Subject: Re: Mickie James or Melina Perez?? Thu 13 Oct 2011, 1:21 am

Better Ring Entrence? Melina... esp in those skirts she used to wear pre-pg era. DAMN!

Better Theme Music? Draw. Both (WWE) themes are catchy. (Hardcore Country is annoying)

Better Ring Attire? Melina has had cooler attire. Mickie has had sexier attire.

Better Face? Mickie. Melina is garbage a a face.

Better Heel? Draw. Mickie was excellent when she debuted in WWE, but her heel run wasn't long. Melina was a great heel but she became boring as hell.

Better Champion? Mickie.

Better Wrestler? Subjective answer on my part bc I'm more of a fan of Mickie (not much of a fan these days - she's kinda boring... but still sexy)

Subject: Re: Mickie James or Melina Perez?? Thu 13 Oct 2011, 7:38 am

Mickie all the way, despite the fact Melina accused Mickie of "copying her style"

bahahaha

Subject: Re: Mickie James or Melina Perez?? Thu 13 Oct 2011, 8:59 am

Better Ring Entrence? Melina
Better Theme Music? Melina
Better Ring Attire? Mickie
Better Face? Mickie
Better Heel? Melina
Better Champion? Mickie
Better Wrestler? Mickie

Subject: Re: Mickie James or Melina Perez?? Thu 13 Oct 2011, 6:23 pm

I don't particularly care for either woman and think they both started off great as wrestlers and personalities but have declined since then. Melinas just overall a complete freak though and I loved psycho lesbian Mickie and when she was Alexis Laree so Mickie for the win

Subject: Re: Mickie James or Melina Perez?? Fri 14 Oct 2011, 12:33 am

Better Ring Entrance? Melina wins; I always liked her splits [both versions].
Better Theme Music? I like them both but Mickie's WWE theme was so catchy; LOL at HBK enjoying it when DX helped Mickie beat Lita while Mickie has shackles on. Mickie James or Melina Perez?? 773246

Better Ring Attire? Again both had great attires but I always liked Melina's top and pant combo a lot because it had tons of cool designs and lots of different colors.
Better Face? Mickie wins this one. She is just very easy to root for.
Better Heel? I would say psycho Mickie but she was only officially heel for like 7 months while Melina did pretty well for a lot longer period of time. So Melina wins this category for me.
Better Champion? Mickie James was a better champ imo.
Better Wrestler? I like them both but I gave the edge to Mickie James.

So it ends up being another 4-3 close call with Mickie winning. I do hope to see them both battle it out in TNA some time soon.

#1 Nattie Fan Number of posts : 1133 Registration date : 2010-07-02

Better Ring Entrance? Melina
Better Theme Music? Mickie
Better Ring Attire? Mickie - fav. was yellow and purple. she seemed to always win in it.
Better Face? Mickie
Better Heel? Psycho Mickie, but Melina was great
Better Champion? Mickie
Better Wrestler? Mickie

Go Mickie (:

Subject: Re: Mickie James or Melina Perez?? Sat 15 Oct 2011, 1:05 pm

Better Ring Entrance? Melina
Better Theme Music? Melina
Better Ring Attire? Melina
Better Face? Mickie
Better Heel? Melina
Better Champion? Mickie
Better Wrestler? Mickie

Subject: Re: Mickie James or Melina Perez?? Sun 16 Oct 2011, 4:25 am

Psycho Mickie was great, but as soon as that died down she just became 'a heel' and wasn't very good at one either.

Subject: Re: Mickie James or Melina Perez?? Sun 16 Oct 2011, 10:51 am

Better Ring Entrence? Melina
Better Theme Music? Melina
Better Ring Attire? Melina
Better Face? Mickie James
Better Heel? Psycho Mickie
Better Champion?Mickie James
Better Wrestler?Mickie James

I think Melina was a really solid performer, but I think Mickie was just a little bit better in the ring.

» Mickie James vs Melina + Backstage Segments, 2-19-07
» Are Melina and Mickie James Diva Legends?
» Mickie James vs Melina + Super Crazy vs Nitro, 2-5-07
» Mickie James & Super Crazy vs Melina & Johnny Nitro, 2-12-07
» Mickie James (with Trish) vs Candice Michelle (with Victoria), + Melina, 11-21-05