Are Melina and Mickie James Diva Legends?

These Two Where the next big thing after Trish and Litas Departure,They Competed in probably one of the greatest Divas Match in History and both had feuds with Trish Stratus in some Amazing matches such as Mickie/Trish WM 22 and Melina/Trish SS.These 2 Brought the Women's Divison Back and IMO two of the Greatest Divas WWE Has Ever Had.

That wasnt Melina though, that was everyone making stuff up remember?

Both won't be remembered. Mickie jobbed out in the last month of her career, Melina jobbed out like the last year of her career.

You never saw the likes of Trish and Lita jobbing out when they left, they left with credibility.

Mickie might make it into TNA Hall of Fame.

They're both already remembered as two of the best. Whatever people think of Melina as a person, no one can honestly question her abilities as a wrestler or performer. Whether that makes them legends, or not, is something history will decide. As it is now, they're considered, along with Beth, the last of the truly great Divas.

Quote :

These 2 Brought the Women's Divison Back

Back from what? They directly inherited the Division from Trish & Lita.

It was a strange situation with them, Beth, & Candice. They were over, but all Vince seemed to see was they weren't as over as Trish & Lita were. So, he shifted to the swimsuit/lingerie/figure models, beginning the Bathroom Break Era of Divas.

But, when the Bathroom Break Era reached it's defining point with the Kelly-Brie feud, with crickets chirping during the matches, the reactions Mickie & Melina got were damn good, in retrospect.

If anything, the Division falling into the state it did after the focus was taken of Mickie & Melina has just enhanced their reputations. Instead of remembering them as the Divas who weren't quite as over as Trish & Lita, they're remembered as representing the last time the Divas were putting on great matches on a regular basis and getting a real reacction.



Melina vs Mickie James- Falls Count Anywhere by TheoMJ21

When Trish Left Mickie Was the Top Face Diva She even sometimes got even a bigger reaction then Trish at some points(Example WM 22).When Lita Left Melina Became the next big heel diva.You Can Say whatever you want about Melina but what she does outside of the ring is not my problem or concern its what she does inside the ring is what I care about because she was a damn good worker.She was a Bitch heel,She had a character a Hollywood Uptight Clebertity and played it really well,as well as being a great manager for MNM I think she even made it into the greatest Managers of all time DVD.She Also Has some great feuds with Torrie,Trish,Beth and of course her best one was with Mickie the Country girl.City vs Country Girl it makes a perfect Feud.Mickie On the Other Hand Played a Very Well Pshyco/Stalker and was complety over when she turned heel she still had the fans cheering for her.She defeated Trish and Lita in two out of 4 of WWE's Biggest PPVs Wrestlemania and Survior Series that's Something Even Michelle McCool say she did first.These 2 were over the fans actually did care about them and although the way they left wasn't the best but who can say besides Trish was ever gonna get a proper goodbye match? Every Diva just gets released And its just shown on WWE.Com that's really all about it now.I think being fired on TV like Bella's,Beth or even Quitting like Eve,Lita is such a lame way to go out.

Mickie had actually lost a lot of momentum by August of 2006, but Lita revived it. Mickie was able to carry the rub Trish & Lita (not to mention Jazz & Victoria) gave her into 2008.

The thing is, a few Divas had big splashes for a couple of years, like Sable, Chyna, Victoria, Mickie, & Melina. What made Trish & Lita unique was sustaining it for several years. They were both hugely over as soon as they debuted. Trish maintained it for the entire 6 1/2 years she was there, & Lita for her first five years until Matt aired her dirty laundry in his quest to destroy her life and career. But, even after that, she was a huge heat magnet until she retired.

The rule in wrestling is everyone is replaceable. Trish & Lita proved the exceptions. They're still trying to replace those two, all these years later. That's what makes then unquestionably the legends of the Division.

Mickie & Melina were the best since them.

I think Melina and Mickie both maintain there popularity threw the years they been there with Mickie's piggy James storyline and Melina with Her feuds with McCool and Beth up until her heel turn at the end of her career.Im pretty sure if they made a return they would Atleast get a crowd reaction because even Trish and Lita sometimes came out to dead crowd reactions when they made a couple of apperences.

Mickie James is a yes but you don't know if WWE will bring her back but she was very solid to this division but the rumors of her attitude and stuff don't know if she will be back. Which is sad in a way. I mean based on titles and acoomplishment she is a legend in women's wrestling with her accomplishments in the big industries that matter.

Melina I don't think so she was a solid wrestler but I don't think she is a legend. She had a good role in the WWE but I wouldn't put her in a legend status by any means.