Gail Kim or Mickie James? Who better?

Who is the better wrestler? Sellar? Carrier? Who has the most charisma? Compare Mickie's best match to Gail's match. Who puts on a better show for the crowd?

DEBATE!

(No Marks Allowed) HAHA kidding

Personally I am a bigger fan of Mickie's, but I will say right now that I think Gail is the better overall wrestler. Mickie's matches are just too repetitive. I LOVED Gail's match with Maryse awhile back (Maryse's last match on SD, I believe.) Mickie has more natural charisma (IMO) but Gail is alot more crisp in her delivery than Mickie is right now....

rather then retype shit skye said it all
all i will add is gail is a better carrier

LL THE GREAT wrote:

all i will add is gail is a better carrier

Oh yeah, she is! She made Maryse look a whole lot better than she really is. (Although I don't think she's that bad)

I like both Gail and Mickie, but Gail is by far the more exciting and able to carry. Mickie is decent, but like it has been said, she can get repetitive at times. I also surprised on how she can't carry as well as I would like her too. Not to mention that her finisher can barely be executed on anyone there except for a few. Gail can carry great, and her finisher isn't too hard for the other Divas to cooperate with.

Mickie for me she is good in the ring and is allow to mess up just liek Gail does,she can carry hell she carried Ashley to a good match of all people,and she can talk on the mic. Also Gail and MAryse worked together on SD their first match together was not good why because they never fought each other which is why Mickie match with Maryse one on one wast alright not great at NOC i bet it be better.

No match with Ashley was ever good. All Ashley matches are in ring tragedies and complete garbage.

I have to say mickie and no its not only because im a bigger fan of mickie i think mickie puts on a better show they both can wrestle and should have the belt but mickie has more charisma she can get the fans up on their feet but gail xould to but mickie does it by just showing up

I like Gail Kim but Mickie has some talent................................

Mickie is all around with wrestling, acting, and talking. Gail is just wrestling.

I can think of Gail being more like a Chris Benoit type of wrestler. Just go in there and just start chopping mother fuckers. He didn't need to say anything that his wrestling couldn't.

so thats why i find her boring most of the time
cos shes the female chris benoit.....i get it now...i couldnt put my finger on it before

Gail is a better wrestler. She has a larger variety of moves to to use on her opponent. She hit's them with much more fluidity than Mickie does.

Mickie has more charisma. She can be face or heel, people just love this woman to death, me included! Guys AND some girls want to fack her. Little girls look up to her. I'm sure she's well respected by her peers.