Better Champion? Mickie James or Michelle McCool?

By default, it's Mickie. She's actually defended that title on the weekly shows since winning it. Michelle on the other hand.. If it wasn't for that NOC PPV, she would've one title defense since she lost the Divas title.

Mickie James....a broom would make a better champion then Michelle

Hands down its definantly Mickie James.

I think Michelle has been doing fine, for what she has been given. Her only credible challenger has been Melina, whereas Mickie has Gail, Beth and Alicia to face off against. Michelle has been more developed as a character through her fued with Melina, whereas Mickie is just 'there' and having random title defences after they win a contendership match.

My vote goes for Michelle just cause shes been fucking up in the ring less

KiwiKevin wrote:

Mickie James....a broom would make a better champion then Michelle

\\


Agreed, lol.

Mickie is much more exciting to watch and she has defended that thing more often.

I hate them both and find them both overrated.

Still voting for Mickie though.
She's somewhat better than Michelle.

im going with X on this one. yes Mickie defends the title on Raw. but in reality shes only had two title defenses herself in 2 months. Also as mentioned Michelle has no credible chalengers, and at least when she does defend the title it "means" more, its taken two months for Mickie to get into a feud. Both Gail and Beths challenge was just random. Michelle/Melina as boring as it has been has more depth and history behind it