QOTR 2009 Round 1 - Rosa Mendes vs Portia Perez

This yearly tournament is held to determine which woman had the most significant year, according to her accomplishments, improvement in wrestling skills and character portrayal, and how the fans perceive her, regardless of whether or not booking favored her.

In this match, you will be voting for ROSA MENDES or PORTIA PEREZ

ROSA MENDES’s 2009 Highlights:
- managed Glamarella in the early stages of the year
- attacked Melina numerous times during Melina’s feud with Beth Phoenix
- was moved to ECW and began to manage Zack Ryder


PORTIA PEREZ’s 2009 Highlights:
- one half of the current Shimmer Tag Team Champions (with Nicole Matthews)
- defeated Kylie Pierce in the inaugural show of NCW Femme Fatales
- challenged Sara del Ray for the JAPW Women’s Championship


Vote and discuss! Thank you for participating in this year’s tournament!

I dont follow Shimmer but I went with Perez, only becasue Rosa really hasnt improved. I really dont like her love story with Ryder as I feel its holding him back.

Rosa has been doing pretty good on WWE but she needs to get out of ECW and go to Smackdown/Raw. Portia is a good wrestler but haven't seen enough of her matches to say if she is better then Rosa. I'll just go Rosa on this one though.

To be honest, I don't know who Portia Perez is, just read the highlights and can already tell she had the better year

I cannot believe Rosa Mendes actually has 8 votes, Where is Brad to vote for Portia?

Portia is my favorite current female wrestler. I love her heel down and dirty style.