New Divas Rankings: Let's go again

With WWE and TNA losing women in recent weeks, let’s do a new Ranking YAAAYYY!!

Here are the options:
Alicia Fox
Beth Phoenix
Brie Bella
Eve Torres
Gail Kim
Jillian Hall
Katie Lea
Kelly Kelly
Layla El
Maryse
Melina
Michelle McCool
Mickie James
Natalya
Nikki Bella
Rosa Mendes
Tiffany
*Note not including Serena, Vickie & Savannah, not main roster wrestlers, only a valet who doesn’t wrestle, enhancement talent and in ring announcer don’t count as wrestlers.

TNA:
Angelina Love
Awesome Kong (She is still listed on the main roster and her contract issues are still unclear)
Daffney
Hamada
Lacey Von Erich
Madison Rayne
ODB
Sarita
Tara
Taylor Wilde
Velvet Sky
*note no Christy, Chelsea or Orlando Jordan’s lady friend because again, not wrestlers on the main roster, so not relevant.

Lastly your top 15 Divas List WWE/TNA merged??? So guess i'm asking for 3 lists.......WWE ranking, TNA ranking and a top 15 ranking of the two company's.

Gonna post mine in a second

Here is my Top list:

WWE List
1. Natalya
2. Beth Phoenix
3. Gail Kim
4. Mickie James
5. Jillian Hall
6. Katie Lea
7. Melina
8. Michelle McCool
9. Alicia Fox
10. Maryse
11. Eve Torres
12. Layla El
13. Tiffany
14. Kelly Kelly
15. Brie Bella
16. Nikki Bella
17. Rosa Mendes

TNA List:
1. Awesome Kong
2. Taylor Wilde
3. Sarita
4. Hamada
5. Tara
6. Angelina Love
7. Madison Rayne
8. ODB
9. Daffney
10. Velvet Sky
11. Lacey von Erich

Top 15 List:
1. Natalya
2. Awesome Kong
3. Beth Phoenix
4. Gail kim
5. Taylor Wilde
6. Sarita
7. Hamada
8. Tara
9. Mickie James
10. Angelina Love
11. Jillian Hall
12. Katie Lea
13. Madison Rayne
14. Melina
15. Michelle McCool

are we rating them based solely on their wrestling and promo skills, or does a win/loss and title defend/win count for something as well?

Wrestling overall, promo skills, acting skills....aside....overall wrestler.

well in terms of wrestling ability

WWE:
1. Gail Kim
2. Melina
3. Natalya
4. Beth Phoenix
5. Mickie James
6. Katie Lea
7. Michelle McCool
8. Alicia Fox
9. Eve Torres
10. Kelly Kelly
11. Jillian Hall
12. Tiffany
13. Layla
14. Nikki Bella
15. Brie Bella
16. Rosa Mendes
17. Maryse

TNA:
1. Tara
2. Hamada
3. Angelina Love
4. Awesome Kong
5. Taylor Wilde
6. Sarita
7. Daffney
8. Madison Rayne
9. ODB
10. Velvet Sky
11. Lacey Von Erich

Top 15:
1. Gail Kim
2.Tara
3. Angelina Love
4. Melina
5.Natalya
6.Hamada
7.Beth Phoenix
8.Mickie James
9. Eve Torres
10. Kelly Kelly
11. Katie Lea
12. Taylor Wilde
13. Alicia Fox
14. Velvet Sky
15. Michelle McCool

Now not gonna bash your list (as laughable as it may be) it's your opinion. But your top 15 does not make sense, how is Hamada ranked higer then Angelina in the TNA list and Angelina is ranked higher then her in the top 15. The point of the Top 15 is to take The top stars in WWE and Top stars in TNA and then according to both lists rank them or well merge them together.

1. WWE list nr. 1
2. WWE list nr. 2
3. TNA List nr. 1
4. WWE list nr. 3
5. TNA list nr. 2

That would seem more logic then:

1. TNA list nr. 2
2. WWE list Nr. 4
3. WWE list nr. 2
4. TNA list nr. 1
5. WWE list nr. 1

Get the drift???


kinda like that.

WWE:
1. Natalya
2. Katie Lea
3. Beth Phoenix
4. Gail Kim
5. Mickie James
6. Jillian Hall
7. Layla El
8. Michelle McCool
9. Alicia Fox
10. Eve Torres
11. Melina
12. Tiffany
13. Maryse
14. Nikkie Bella
15. Brie Bella
16. Kelly Kelly
17. Rosa Mendes

TNA:
1. Hamada
2. Sarita
3. Taylor Wilde
4. ODB
5. Kong
6. Tara
7. Daffney
8. Angelina Love
9. Madison Rayne
10. Velvet Sky
11. Lacey Von Erich

Overall:
1. Natalya
2. Hamada
3. Sarita
4. Taylor Wilde
5. Mickie James
6. ODB
7. Kong
8. Katie Lea
9. Beth Phoenix
10. Gail Kim
11. Kong
12. Jillian Hall
13. Tara
14. Layla El
15. Michelle McCool
16. Alicia Fox
17. Daffney
18. Angelina Love
19. Eve Torres
20. Melina
21. Madison Rayne
22. Velvet Sky
23. Tiffany
24. Maryse
25. Nikki Bella
26. Brie Bella
27. Lacey Von Erich
28. Kelly Kelly
29. Rosa Mendes

Maryse better then Layla as a wrestler? i thought even you said that werent true >.< bahahhaha
i will get on to it later

WWE
1.Beth Phoenix (MUST BE NUMBER ONE!!!)
2.Gail Kim (Out wrestles all the ho's of Raw by a mile<3)
3.Michelle McCool (extremely underrated, on paper she might be worse than Melina, Mickie, Katie, Natalya, Jillian but I dont give a shit, she's awesome to watch in the ring<3)
4.Jillian (gets a lot of flack, clotheslining every b***** in sight<3)
5.Mickie James (Stepped up big time on SD)
6.Natalya
7.Melina
8.Alicia Fox
9.Katie Lea
10.Nikki Bella
11.Layla
12.Tiffany
13.Brie Bella
14.Eve Torres
15.Rosa Mendes
16.Kelly Kelly
17.Maryse


Seriously Maryse is bad! I dont know what happened to her ass but she needs to get her shit together, Kelly is just ugh!


TNA
1.Taylor Wilde<3
2.Sarita
3.Kong
4.Angelina Love
5.Madison Rayne
6.Hamada
7.ODB
8.Tara
9.Daffney
10.Velvet Sky
11.Lacey


Overall
Taylor Wilde
Sarita
Beth Phoenix
Gail Kim
Awesome Kong
Michelle McCool
Angelina Love
Madison Rayne
Hamada
Jillian
Mickie James
Natalya
Melina
Alicia Fox
ODB

You are so biased, Blue, like seriously...

Shannon Moore Version 2.0 wrote:

You are so biased, Blue, like seriously...

I dont care?



Post your list, I must see where you rank Kelleh!

My take in the WWE is always this:
Top Tier
natalya, Beth & Gail always debateable who is the best. All deserve it, all for diffrent reasons

Second Tier:
Katie lea, Melina, Jillian and Micke, again a debateable group, you can mix and match em, but again doesn't bother me much seeing them rearganged. All four Botchy, two are akward and two are just meh sometimes. While all four HIGHLY overrated. Can we call this one the OVER RATED TIER?

Taker Tier:
Michelle McCool, she's in a league of her own tbh. Not good, not bad.

Fourth Tier:
Alicia Fox, Tiffany, Eve Torres, Layla El, Maryse-The Simply bad group, mix and match em, doesn't bother me either. Their all bad, just really it doesn't matter who's worst they are all just as bad. Finding their good is what makes it a challenge.

Fifth Tier:
The Bella's & Kelly Kelly, they are just awfull, on the bottom, but doesn't bother me, who is where.

Sixth Tier:
Rosa Mendes- there is just no hope anymore, done deal,pack up and leave, your one step behind uselless (which is Tier 6)

That's just how i view the divas when it comes to actual wrestling ability.

I'm doing my list later

WWE
1. Natalya
2. Gail Kim
3. Mickie James
4. Melina
5. Maryse
6. Layla El
7. Beth Phoenix
8. Michelle McCool
9. Tiffany
10. Alicia Fox
11. Kelly Kelly
12. Katie Lea
13. Jillian Hall
14. Eve Torres
15. Brie Bella
16. Nikki Bella
17. Rosa Mendes

TNA
1. Sarita
2. Tara
3. Taylor Wilde
4. Velvet Sky
5. Angelina Love
6. Awesome Kong
7. Hamada
8. ODB
9. Daffney
10. Madison Rayne
11. Lacey Von Erich

Top 15
1. Sarita
2. Natalya
3. Gail Kim
4. Mickie James
5. Tara
6. Melina
7. Taylor Wilde
8. Maryse
9. Layla El
10. Velvet Sky
11. Beth Phoenix
12. Angelina Love
13. Michelle McCool
14. Tiffany
15. Awesome Kong

I don't like Kelly that much anymore. Its been over a year since I first joined, ya know.

something i need help with
how can ppl judge one bella over the other...firstly i cant tell one from the other
and secondly Blue...how can you rate her a better wrestler then Layla...when we dont even see her wrestle

but eh

once again..mine is in progress

I can tell the Bellas apart so I'll be judging them apart as well

WWE:
1.Beth Phoenix
2.Nattie
3.Gail
4.Melina
5.Mickie James
6.Katie Lea
7.Jillian
8.Michelle McCool
9.Alicia Fox
10.Layla
11.Eve
12.Tiffany
13.Nikki Bella
14.Brie Bella
15.Kelly
16.Rosa
17.Maryse

TNA Knockouts:
1.Taylor Wilde
2.Sarita
3.Kong
4.Hamada
5.Tara
6.Daffney
7.ODB
8.Angelina Love
9.Madison Rayne
10.Velvet Sky
11.Lacey

Overall:
1. Beth Phoenix
2. Natalya
3. Gail
4. Taylor Wilde
5. Melina
6. Sarita
7. Kong
8. Hamada
9. Tara
10. Mickie James
11. Daffney
12. Katie Lea
13. Jillian
14. Angelina Love
15. Michelle McCool

FARMSTA FARMSTA LL wrote:

something i need help with
how can ppl judge one bella over the other

honestly i'd say their in-ring skill is the same...but i like Nikki more. so i ranked her higher.

Their in-ring skill is not the same. I remember one of their matches on Superstars when Nikki got the hot tag and was on fire, she actually looked a bit good in there.

WWE List
1. Gail Kim
2. Natalya
3. Beth Phoenix
4. Mickie James
5. Jillian Hall
6. Melina
7. Michelle McCool
8. Katie Lea
9. Eve Torres
10. Tiffany
11. Layla El
12. Alicia
13. Maryse
14. Brie Bella
15. Nikki Bella
16. Kelly Kelly
17. Rosa Mendes

TNA List:
1. Tara
2. Taylor Wilde
3. Hamada
4. Sarita
5. Daffney
6. Angelina Love
7. Madison Rayne
8. ODB
9. Velvet Sky
10. Lacey von Erich

Top 15 List:
1. Gail Kim
2. Tara
3. Natalya
4. Beth Phoenix
5. Taylor Wilde
6. Mickie James
7. Hamada
8. Sarita
9. Daffney
10. Jillian
11. Melina
12. Michelle McCool
13. Katie Lea
14. Eve Torres
15. Madison Rayne