Angelina Love or Michelle McCool?

Who is better suited to be a champion?
Who has better mic skills?
Who plays the better face?
Who plays the better heel?
Who has better in-ring skills?

Why do you think so?

Who is better suited to be a champion?
I think both were pretty suited to be champion, both are very good athletes and very good wrestlers

Who has better mic skills?
Depending on what type of script they are given. Because i personally find both to be dry, both have pretty naff accents, which doesnt help

Who plays the better face?
Neither

Who plays the better heel?
Both play good heels imo.

Who has better in-ring skills?
I think Angelina has more ring knowledge. But I think McCool is a better executer

Why do you think so?
i guess i sorta explained it following each answer haha

but this is just my opinion though. I think really liked both

Thanks for making this one easy, Vix.

Who is better suited to be a champion?
What kind of question is this? When you've been subjected to BOTH as champion as long as we have, it's very difficult to point out why one is better than the other. Orton/Cena much?


Who has better mic skills?
I think they're about even. But if I had to choose, I'd give the advantage to Angelina.

Who plays the better face?
I think I'm going to have to say A. Love. I think it's more about TNA's style as opposed to the difference between the two girls. No one KO dominates and wins every damn match.

Who plays the better heel?
I am going to say Angelina by a slim margin. For most of Michelle's run, she played the immature Head Cheerleader that you see in every teen flick. How cliche? Not only has Angelina done that and done it well. She has expanded her game well beyond that. Zombie? Check. A little lesbian tease? Throw that in there as well. Now, we're seeing her as a toned down version of her "Beautiful People" gimmick. How's that for versatility?

Who has better in-ring skills?
For me, it isn't close: Michelle. She was pimpin' by the end of her career. Angelina can go, but Michelle is just better.

Why do you think so?
Overall, I'm going with Angelina. As I pointed out before: the style of TNA allows Angelina to have in interesting personality - and despite her many championships, I'd rather watch her and other solid workers over over what McCool was doing with many more shitty workers )and a few strong ones.)

Shimmer Mark wrote:

Who has better in-ring skills?
I agree with LL, Angelina seemed to have more knowledge in the ring, but Michelle was a fantastic executor.

This.

Who is better suited to be a champion? Michelle
Who has better mic skills? Angelina
Who plays the better face? Angelina
Who plays the better heel? Michelle
Who has better in-ring skills? Michelle

Knowledge of the Game wrote:

Thanks for making this one easy, Vix.

you know what...




and you all didnt have to answer 'why do you think so" as a separate question..i just wanted to be sure people elaborate on their responses. gets some good discussion going.

Yeah this was pretty cool to do so I hope you make more threads like this because I'll probably reply to all of them.

The Sexy Vixen wrote:

Knowledge of the Game wrote:

Thanks for making this one easy, Vix.

you know what...




and you all didnt have to answer 'why do you think so" as a separate question..i just wanted to be sure people elaborate on their responses. gets some good discussion going.

I'm teasing you.

I would go with Angelina, she only has ONE major downfall that has been bothering me for over 3 years now.

I see Angelina, I see a girl who can GO in the ring, like really go out there and wrestle amazing matches. BUT she isn't. Angelina is such a technically strong wrestler, her excecutions of the simplest moves are just intact and performed perfectly. I remember in her early TNA career she had one of the best looking crossbody's out there. Great height, great excecution, great timing everything.

I just don't know why she doesn't just wrestle to her full potential. I used to blame TNA match bookers but then looking at her work outside of TNA it's the same thing. I don't know if she needs someone to come out and beat it out of her and push her to her limits. But it's HIGHLY frustrating to sit there and watch someone wrestle on an average level knowing this person could do a WHOLE lot more.