Which Brand has the best talent?

Raw:
Maryse
Beth Phoenix
Brie Bella
Jillian
Kelly Kelly
Maryse
Mickie James
Nikki Bella
Rosa Mendes

Smackdown:
Melina
Alicia Fox
Candice Michelle
Eve
Gail Kim
Layla
Maria
Michelle McCool

ECW:
Katie Lea
Natalya

place your votes, everyone.

ECW, just based on Nattie and Katie alone. if beth was with them they would be unstoppable.

SMACKDOWN HANDS DOWN! I’m not being biased either because I’m a huge Layla mark.

Raw has?
Mickie James, Jillian Hall and Beth Pheonix? That’s three great talents.
ECW has two jobbers
SD Has Michelle, Melina, Gail Kim, Candice Michelle and the ever improving Alicia Fox and Layla.

SD wins by a mile!

Michelle, candice and layla arent Great Talents...so SD is tied with Raw, i think, if anything.

(3-3)

by your logic, Maryse is a great talent...and we all know she is still improvig.

I didn’t say Candice, Layla were great talent LMAO! I just prefer them to The Bella’s and Kelly.

Oh shit I forgot Maryse too lol

wow you forgot the diva's champ

for shame

Meh, her overrated-ness completely turns me off. I forgot about her on purpose lol

how's she overrated? she hasnt done anything. lol

i just think she's good at being a snob...and she's improving a bit.

Don’t get me wrong, I love me some Maryse but when ppl on other forums had the gaw to say she’s better at wrestling then Michelle McCool? That turned me off, I was like “Are you fucking kidding me” The girl is improving but she’s nowhere near Michelle’s level as far as wrestling goes.

i dont think she's better than anyone...'cept kelly....and trashley...and maria....

but she still has a long way to go.

The Blue Man wrote:

Don’t get me wrong, I love me some Maryse but when ppl on other forums had the gaw to say she’s better at wrestling then Michelle McCool? That turned me off, I was like “Are you fucking kidding me” The girl is improving but she’s nowhere near Michelle’s level as far as wrestling goes.

That's what you get for visiting the WWE Universe Forum.


Haven't you seen the various posts and topics that some of us have made regarding the idiocy of some of the people on that forum. I mean some of those people think that Rosa Mendes is a great wrestler on par with Jillian Hall and Katie Lea for god's sake.

LMAO Tell me about it! WWE Universe is FULL of marks.... Every forum has them but WWE Universe is on a whole other level.

Honestly both raw & smackdown are tied with useless non-talent, and since it doesn't seem like either show is better, I 'm gonna just go with ECW, even though I doubt they'll book Natalya vs Katie seeing as though they're both Heels.

I voted for Smackdown because all the wrestlers on RAW are oldies when you think SD has all this fresh talent going around that can become so much better, even now they're brilliant anyway

SD-It has Melina, Gail, and decent wrestlers in Michelle, Candice and Alcia and the improving Layla and Eve.

Raw just has Beth, Mickie and Jillian.

ECW has Nattie and Katie but both are being misused.

So SD gets my vote.

EEEEEKKKKKKK I’m literally excited for the new SD, I love all girls on that roster except Maria…. Next Friday can’t come fast enough lol

next friday might be the same ol same ol since MVP will still be on SD to defend his title. so dont be shocked if melina isnt there yet...i'm thinking the week after it will go i effect

Oh yea forgot about that lol, Im getting impatient now lol

no as off this mondays raw the draft is in effect
its just this saturday there is a us title match....what is confusing me however is to why they have started a feud with dolph and mvp when they are on different brands
they shoulda just kept dolph on raw

you never know, LL...WWE can change teir minds.

nothing is ever set in stone with them.

your right i guess
so why do people talk like things are (D) lol

because it's a figure of speech...you take things too literal when you read posts.

Raw's got the better talent:

Beth - wrestling
Mickie - wrestling
Jillian - wrestling
Maryse - personality
Kelly - popular

SD's only great wrestler is Gail Kim. Melina's good but she's not better than any of the experienced divas on RAW. RAW also has the more over divas (Mickie and Kelly) while SD only has Maria who is legitmately over.

ECW doesn't even count. Natalya is the best women's wrestler in the WWE period but it makes no difference for me to say that ECW has the better talent despite having two very experienced women on the roster because both of them are relegated to 'valet' roles.

SD has definitely been booked better as of a late but the question wasn't which roster had the better division, it's which one had the better talent and RAW's three experienced divas alone trump SD's entire division.

*DR LL* wrote:

no as off this mondays raw the draft is in effect
its just this saturday there is a us title match....what is confusing me however is to why they have started a feud with dolph and mvp when they are on different brands
they shoulda just kept dolph on raw

challenges for a title being made doesnt mean a feud is starting.....

Hmmm lets see

Mickie is a great wrestler but VERY stale for a few years now!
Beth is a great wrestler but again VERY stale, she tends to get boring after a while.
Jillian is a great wrestler but her role as a jobber overshadows that in my opinion.
Kelly is popular and sucks in the ring lol, Hell her popularity seems to be decreasing as of late
Maryse is a great personality and alright in the ring….

Plus they have Santina Marella, if Raw was any indication then the supposed “Better division” will all about a man in drag in the coming weeks, not looking forward to that!

Now SD has

Candice Michelle- Former Champion and decent in her own right
Michelle McCool-First ever divas champion and made the transition to wrestler, something few models were able to do
Melina-A great wrestler who tends to be sloppy but has managed to get over, Maria is not the only popular diva in the Blue Brand.
Gail Kim-Great wrestler and former champ

Layla, Alicia Fox and Eve Torres- The decent up and comers

Maria-The popular jobber

Overall SD just PWNS Raw as far as divas go, also the question was about “Better Division” But I think its overall talent lol

the question is better talent, Blue. and i think StratusOrton hit the nail on the head

Raw has the better talent. SD just has better booking

The Blue Man wrote:

Hmmm lets see

Mickie is a great wrestler but VERY stale for a few years now!
Beth is a great wrestler but again VERY stale, she tends to get boring after a while.
Jillian is a great wrestler but her role as a jobber overshadows that in my opinion.
Kelly is popular and sucks in the ring lol, Hell her popularity seems to be decreasing as of late
Maryse is a great personality and alright in the ring….

Plus they have Santina Marella, if Raw was any indication then the supposed “Better division” will all about a man in drag in the coming weeks, not looking forward to that!

Now SD has

Candice Michelle- Former Champion and decent in her own right
Michelle McCool-First ever divas champion and made the transition to wrestler, something few models were able to do
Melina-A great wrestler who tends to be sloppy but has managed to get over, Maria is not the only popular diva in the Blue Brand.
Gail Kim-Great wrestler and former champ

Layla, Alicia Fox and Eve Torres- The decent up and comers

Maria-The popular jobber

Overall SD just PWNS Raw as far as divas go, also the question was about “Better Division” But I think its overall talent lol

Again I disagree with you. I think Candice is mediocre in the ring. I think Michelle is decent at best. Layla, Alicia and Eve have potential, they haven't even reached decent in the ring yet. Melina is a good wrestler. Sloppy, a bit more innovative than the other divas but again, she's not a better wrestler than Beth, Jillian or Mickie.

Regardless if their movesets are stale or not, it doesn't deter from their 'talent'. It's not their fault how they're booked in the ring. Just because their moveset may be repetitive now (which is the same for Michelle as well who basically does the same staple moves in her matches), the fact is, talent isn't measured by what you see from match to match but with overall ability and potential. Repetitive or not, the abilities of Beth, Jillian and Mickie are better than Maria, Michelle, Candice, Layla, Eve and Alicia combined. I personally think it's impossible to say that SD has the better talent. Like I said, talk about better division, that's a different story, but as far as talent, I don't think there's any room for debate, RAW has it in spades compared to SD, WWE just doesn't use the RAW girls properly.