Jackie Gayda vs Ashley Massaro

Who do you prefer? Both are horrible botch queens, imo...but if I had to choose, I'd prefer to look at Jackie over Ashley.

Jackie hands down..she got her wrestling together by the end of her career. Ashley just sucked from the day she was signed, to the day she was fired.

yeah jackie wasnt a botch queen
she botched badly at the beginning of her career..but so do most people
coming to the end of career she was better
and then what does the silly moose do, get knocked up

Who isn't better than Ashley?

The Hitman wrote:

Who isn't better than Ashley?

I suppose a dead person?

Jackie, At first I really dislike her but once I met her and found out how much of a nice person she was, I liked her from that moment.

Yeah Jackie did get better torwards the end.

I also think Jackie was willing to get better and Ashley didnt seem too willing.

and also what i think is better is that Jackie got into wwe through tough enough
where they trained to wrestle and shit whilst getting through the contest

where as ashley was part of the ds, where they didn random little girly contests and shit

WWE Diva bootcamp

There's no competiton. Jackie always seemed to have passion and drive,she was eger to learn ,where as ashley massaro was a poser who thought she could wrestle!

I voted for Ashley just to be a rebel without a cause.

I dunno. I don't have a problem with Jackie or Ashley.

But judging by their booking, they just gave up on Jackie. She started out of the gate as someone they really wanted to use, but was too green and/or just not cut out for the wrestling side. I don't even know if she had more than 5 matches while she was in the WWE.

Ashley, poser or not, I do think the passion was there. As many injuries as she's had and kept on truckin' says a lot to me. It was clear that she wasn't meant to be an in-ring performer, but I thought she did great as a manager/spot monkey.