WD's Next Top Model Season 3 *JUDGES ONLY* Thread

Once I receive all of the photos from the participants, I will post them in here.

PLEASE NOTE: Only Judges can post in here.

This is how the judging will go down.

The judges will make a comment about every photo, but they will not score it!

After they make their comments they are to score each photo from 0-10, and pm me those scores.

Once I receive all of the judges scores, I will add up the scores. Ex: Layla- Judge 1: 8 Judge 2: 9 Judge 3: 5.... so 8+9+5= 22pts total.

The person with the lowest score will be eliminated, so choose you pictures wisely!

Warning: I trust my judges, but if I feel that you are being biased towards a certain Wrestler, or giving bad score to a wrestler you hate... YOU WILL BE REPLACED!

Happy Judging!

Challenge 1

Brie

Nikki


Kelly Kelly

Alicia Fox


AJ

Natalya


Eve

Candice Michelle


Brooke

Velvet


Kaitlyn

Layla


Rosa

Winter


Maryse

Beth Phoenix

Challenge # 1: Little Black Dress

Brie: She looks pretty good. You can't see the dress that well from her pose but it is different. I like her head band and her ring stands out.

Nikki: Brie had a much better photo imo. Nikki's is not that great. The dress is ugly to me. I don't like the turtle neck part and the lower part of the dress makes her look like she has big belly when she clearly does not. Her hair is also a little messy. They could have Photoshopped some of the loose pieces away. Overall it's not my favorite.

Kelly: Her picture is good. I mean nothing I can really say is wrong. The dress is a little plain but other than that it is solid.

Alicia: This is a nice change so far. A little black dress that has some color to it! I don't really know what that is but it is different.. The photo's quality could be better though.

AJ: I remember this photo shoot. It is perfect for AJ since she is a gamer and the background is Space Invader-ish. Her dress is good and the slight pink matches her lips perfectly. Her face and hair are also good. The bangle bracelets and high top Chucks are classic AJ.

Natalya: She looks really pretty in this picture. I like the pose and with the white background she stands out a lot. I think her shoes should have been red to match her lips but still it is so far one of my favorites.

Eve: She looks hot. Her face and most of the dress are awesome. I like the lace detail above her boobs. :p The only thing negative I have to say is the ruffle thing on the dress. It would be better if that was not there.

Candice: I'm not a big fan of this picture. Her dress is okay it just doesn't stand out much for me. And Idk why but I'm not a fan of Candice's face in this picture..

Tessmacher: WTF with the setting.. Idk what TNA was thinking. Miss Tessmacher looks good in her face/hair and the body except her stance which I think looks awkward. Also wtf is going on with her right titty? Her poor titty looks messed up!

Velvet: This is a much better picture of a KO. Velvet looks fantastic. She is smiling, her little black dress looks great on its own but is backed up with the earrings, and bracelet. She stands out from the background as well.

Kaitlyn: It is an acceptable picture. Nothing horribly wrong or right about it. Her hair and body are good however the little black dress is plain and I am not a fan of the knee high boots.

Layla: Again the dress is a little plain. It's almost like Layla and Kaitlyn have the same dress. I just think it could be better. Layla's face is also a little hidden by her hair. It would have looked better had it not been that way. As the winner from last year I expect more from Layla so come on girl step it up!

Rosa: I think Rosa looks perfectly acceptable. The dress is again a little average however she is trying her hardest to show off her assets. She should have no problems moving on imo but if she is to win a challenge she needs to send in a better photo.

Winter: This look is very 'Winter.' I am not the biggest fan of her style however it is for sure unique which earns her some points. The hair and face are on point I just don't love the pose specifically her left foot which looks a little weird. :-/

Maryse: First off I hope that is fake fur.. Besides that Maryse looks really great in this picture. Her dress stands out for sure and has some good details to it. Her accessories add to the picture and it doesn't hurt that her hair and face are strong either.

Beth: Beth's face is very striking in this picture. I like her old Hollywood-esq hair and the red lips/fingernails. Her dress is also the only one that has straps like that so it makes her different and stand out.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

That's what I think of the first week's photos.

I'm interested in what my fellow judges have to say.

Good luck to everyone and I'll send my scores to you Keri soon.

Brie: Cute picture! I love the hair and face and pose.
Nikki: This picture looks very plain to me, nothing really sticks out about it. I like her shoes tho!
Kelly Kelly: This picture screams 'Sexy Secretary'
Alicia: I'm not one for plain backgrounds. But this pic is fun. I like her dress, it looks like a long shirt.
AJ: This pic is cute, she looks like a 'naughty gamer'. Her shoes are the best.
Natalya: Great picture. Love the dress, pose, shoes, face, hair. Even the white background looks pretty good with this pic.
Eve: Cute dress, I don't like the hair or face though.
Candace: Good picture, pose and dress are great!
Brooke: Best background photo.
Velvet: This is a cute simple picture. I like everything about it.
Kaitlyn: Those shoes look horrible with that dress. I;m not a big fan of this picture.
Layla: Good Picture, but bad hair.
Rosa: Good Picture, good pose.
Winter: Good Picture, I like the whole outfit.
Maryse: Great Picture. No criticism from me! (Best photo of the week from me)
Beth: Great Picture. No criticism from me!

Brie: You look fabulous. Nice pose, dress and shoes.

Nikki: The dress isnt doing you any favors.

Kelly: You look like a young Nicole Kidman

Alicia: The dress is kinda making me think 'wtf'

AJ: the shoes take focus away from the dress

Natalya: You look like you're having fun. Total glamour shot

Eve: a little too much tanning my dear but that is a lovely dress

Candice: You look so innocent yet your dress just screams 'if you only knew...'

Brooke: Sexy

Velvet: The shoes are a bit much.

Kaitlyn: I love your hair.. the boots were a very unique touch.

Layla: That pose is delicious.

Rosa: This outfit is all you.

Winter: the dress is a bit idk..

Maryse: The jewelry makes this outfit complete.

Beth: Vicious Vixen should be your nickname

Challenge 2

Brie


Eve

Candace Michelle


Kelly Kelly

Alicia Fox


Kaitlyn

Layla


Rosa

Winter


AJ

Natalya


Velvet

Brooke


Maryse

Beth Phoenix

Brie: this just isnt your week. The pose, the attire...both are all wrong.

Eve: The dress color is all wrong. The pose looks awkward and are you on a beach?

Candace: Eww Duck Lips...and animal print isnt really fall attire

Kelly: Simple yet lovely. Nice job this week.

Alicia: granted i have no issue with yellow being a fall color but i was thinking more of a pale/pastel type of yellow. Good Outfit though

Kaitlyn: Not at all Fall like but still not exactly the worst picture i've seen this week.

Layla: Too much summer but sexy nonetheless

Rosa: Pretty good choice minus the colors being completely wrong.

Winter: Sex sells but not for this week's competition

AJ: as adorable as you are it isnt enough for me to give you a pass this week.

Natalya: All I can say to this is...no.

Velvet: animal prints... -shudders-

Brooke: Nicely done. Could've added a bit more but nobody's perfect.

Maryse: A bit plain but still not the worst pic of this bunch

Beth: Sexy but still needed more

BOOM HEADSHOT

Brie: Unlike my other judges, I think this is one of the better pictures this week. It shows more fall then most of the other photos.
Eve: Beach= summer or spring. Bad choice
Candice: This pic is ok. Regardless of the animal print dress. I like the bronze background, I can see that being a fall color.
Kelly Kelly: This scares nothing about fall to me what so ever. (Whats with all the white backgrounds, it's not doing her any justice)
Alicia: Wrong kind of yellow.
Kaitlyn: This was 'fall' themed, not 'best ring attire' theme.
Layla: I don't know anyone who wears bikinis in the fall.
Rosa:I can see this being kinda fall. It's a good pic, it'll pass by me.
Winter:This is a pretty good pic too.
AJ: This pic is just absolutely horrible. Tho I cannot ignore the fact that is actually the right color orange for fall.
Natalya: Is she trying to seduce the wall? No, just no
Velvet: She looks like she's about to go to a party!
Brooke: Really nice photo. The pose, the chair, the props, I like.
Maryse: I like this pic because she is not wearing a lot of make-up and it shows her natural beauty. Her shirt is a fall color too
Beth: She looks like a detectives sexy partner in the photo, lol. Not bad tho

Challenge 3 Photos

Brie


Kaitlyn

Layla


Alicia

Kelly Kelly


Rosa

Winter


Candace

Eve


AJ


Brooke

Velvet


Maryse

**Please ignore the watermark
Beth Phoenix

Brie: Simply beautiful. Love the dress and pose.
Kaitlyn: Def. her best photo yet. I like everything about it besides her face and the way it's turned away.
Layla: Good photo. I love the whole 'wild' aspect of it.
Alicia: Simple yet dazzling.
Kelly Kelly: Flawless body, and the background looks great in this picture.
Rose: Too plain, but it does incorporate the theme.
Winter: I love the purple animal print. But it is also very plain.
Candace: Very seductive pose and outfit. Great photo!
Eve: Really like the outfit! And the background looks lovely as well.
AJ: AJ and the dress look great! But the background looks horrible out of place.
Brooke: Very sexy and fun.
Velvet: Great use of the theme. Great photo!
Maryse: Love the dress. She looks beautiful. Great photo!
Beth: Nice photo: I like her hair, and her animal cover.

Brie: Great pose and attire...beautiful all around...except the confuzzling look on your face

Kaitlyn: Awesome attire but the pose is weird

Layla: Very Sexy and I love the lighting.

Alicia: Cute...nothing flashy or special..just a genuinely good pic

Kelly Kelly: Very nice hun. sweet but still sexy

Rosa: Nice shirt...not what I was expecting.

Winter: Uniqueness is always nice.

Candace: Looks like you want to seduce the judges...

Eve: I like the pose and scenery

AJ: Looks like our little AJ is growing into a beautiful young woman

Brooke: You just look like you're having a blast on the beach. Great job

Velvet: The pose is awkward but otherwise I like it

Maryse: the dress is nice but the design is kinda bleh to me. Great pic though

Beth: Classic Beauty...i love it..i really do.

Challenge 4 Photos

Brie:


Kaitlyn:

Layla:


Alicia:

Kelly Kelly:


Rose:


Candace:

Eve:


AJ:


Brooke:

Velvet:


Maryse:

Beth:

Brie: Beautiful. Love the pose on the steps. The dress and shoes look great too.
Kaitlyn: This is cute, but plain.
Layla: Very flashy and glamorous.
Alicia: This would be considered "Laying". But I do think its cute and I love the black and white effect.
Kelly Kelly: "Laying" again. Nice pose and all but her face looks horrible.
Rosa: Stunning. I love the blue dress. Her hair looks great too.
Candace: Face looks a little weird but other then that great picture.
Eve: Great photo! I love the effect the red lips and shoes have to the picture!.
AJ: Cute
Brooke: Beautiful and cute. Love the pose and the shoes. Great smile!
Velvet: Cute. I like her pose and dress.
Beth: Pretty, nice, and elegant!
Maryse: Great Photo! Love the outfit and the background!

Brie: You look so innocent yet seductive
Kaitlyn: That is a weird smile
Layla: All eyes and cameras are definitely on you
Alicia: 'Sitting'....not 'Laying'
Kelly: see above comment
Rosa: You look gorgeous, love the dress
Candace: a sexy tomboy
Eve: too much makeup and not really feeling the outfit
AJ: Makes me want to have a sleepover
Brooke: You look comfy yet sexy
Velvet: Cute...just all around cute
Maryse: Sexy
Beth: sophisticated

Challenge 5 Photos

Bree


Layla


Alicia


AJ


Eve

Candace


Beth

Maryse


Brooke

Velvet


Rosa

Brie: As much as I hate the steelers....your costume looks great

Layla: Lookin good

Alicia: I think this fits you well

AJ: so bright..and it seems more christmas-y then Halloween.

Eve: Cant see the costume really well but it looks good.

Candace: Meow! very sexy, catwoman

Beth: looks great but the title belt totally clashes with that outfit

Maryse: The french delight always seems to impress

Brooke: you look a tad uncomfortable but nice costume

Velvet: for some reason i wouldnt mind you haunting my dreams

Rosa: Muy caliente, dear

Brie: GO STEELERS!!! Unlike my other judges I love the steelers! Nice perk! lol
Layla: Nice outfit! RIP MJ
Alicia: Cute lil costume.
AJ: She looks like she's going to a high school costume party.
Eve: Great photo!
Candace: I don't think that looks anything like Candace, but it is sexy.
Beth: Decent costume, not all slutty like some other ones.
Maryse: I'm sure many guys, or girls, would love for her to be their 'maid'
Brooke: Nice costume. Her position looks weird though.
Velvet: Best picture of the week in my opinion. Halloween is all about scary!
Rose: Nice costume but she looks super weird.

Challenge 6 Photos

Brie


Alicia


Candace

Eve


Velvet


Layla


Rosa


AJ


Maryse

Beth

Brie: Amazing suit but your pose looks so awkward...and makes your body look deformed.

Alicia: Sexy...just sexy

Candace: not a fan of the facial expression

Eve: Nice pose...very seductive

Velvet: Looks like you're having fun

Layla: a nice seductive stroll

Rosa: Not even in a bikini but you make the it look good.

AJ: Not feeling the bracelets but love the bikini

Maryse: Sexy as always

Beth: Headband not needed but the whole scene works for you, Glamazon

Challenge # 6: Beach

Brie: I think everything is great about this picture besides Brie's pose. If that was different I think she could easily win the week. I don't see her getting eliminated but you never know I mean Brooke went last week! The theme this time is beach and I think she has one of the best beach locations so I'll highly take that into consideration with my score.

Alicia: Her boobs look really big in this picture! Good picture though. I like how the green stands out a lot in the dark background. Usually most beach shots are in the daytime so this is unique.

Candice: The picture is tiny! I think it is overall good although I think the hair and face could be stronger. The bikini and beach background are perfectly acceptable.

Eve: Another really small picture. I think this picture is solid. I like the pose and what I can see of her bikini. The water is also nice in this shot.

Velvet: The scenery is very nice. Such a pretty blue. I think Velvet looks perfectly fine in the picture but because she is next to Angelina it takes away from her. I am almost more drawn to Love than Velvet and that isn't that good. Also it is another leopard print attire for Velvet and maybe it should be the last one..?

Layla: Most of this picture is solid but I think it looks odd because her left arm is nowhere to be seen and it almost looks like she had it amputated! I just think she could be better. Also the beach doesn't look too fun at least I think it looks cold so poor Layla having to be there for probably a long time.. She'll likely scoot by but again could better for me at least.

Rosa: Wow Rosa's picture surprised me. It is probably my favorite of hers overall so far so congrats on improving so much. Like Alicia the time of day makes this shot stand out and I like pose.

AJ: I am not a big fan of her pose but the bikini and background are positives.

Maryse: Another great photo from the most consistent woman this season. I like the photo a lot. Win # 2 to come..?

Beth: This is a different shot in that there is not sand or water in it whereas all the others have at least one or the other. It does have some nice palm trees though and Beth looks well. I think this is another picture from Beth that should keep her safe but not win the week. Gotta step it up though.

Sorry I'm late, I was dealing with some personal issues.

Brie - I love the swimsuit. it looks great but not so great on you. it seems to be really digging into your waist and giving you a bad case of the camel toe, it also makes your boobs look nonexistent, the pose is kind of bland too, but I do like your hair and the rocks are nice.


Alicia - I like the color of your swimsuit, it really stands out against the blueish gray background, the pose is nice and you look good, but I think it could have been better.

Candace: You look AMAZING in white, it's simple yet sexy. Great job!

Eve: you look a little uncomfortable in this pic, it looks like you're just laying there waiting for it to do over with it, though I will admit you look good when you're "bored"

Velvet: I love that your hair matches your bikini (lol) I think your body looks great, my only problem is the top, it's sagging which causes your boobs to look weird. Ohh and seeing you wearing next to nothing while standing next to Angelina really makes her look like a crackhead.

Layla: You're soo hot in this picture you're giving the sand a boner! I love these colors on you, I could do without the jewelry though, it doesn't match anything and it just seems like a waste.

Rosa: My second favorite photo of the week, you look fucking AMAZING! YOU FACE LOOKS FLAWLESS!!! Everything in this photo is working perfectly for you! The lighting, the location, the waves....PERFECTION!

AJ: I sorry but NO! NO! NO! NO! It looks like you're wearing granny panties and that green wrist band doesn't match a thing that you're wearing, you could have done sooo much better.

Maryse: I'm speechless....... I thought Rosa had the best photo until I saw yours. I LOVE LOVE LOVE Your bikini the color is fantastic! That purple looks great on you, and your boobs defy gravity, how do u do that?? Your face is gorgeous, no one is serving as much face as you are, I love the with nail polish against your tan skin, You made this challenge your bitch and you owned it!

Beth - YOU ARE A GLAMAZON! Even with little to no make-up you are still as sexy as can be! It looks like you're out in Themyscira kicking it with Wonder Woman, it's a great photo, my only complaint is the outfit, the design of it is nice and it fits you well, the color is just dull, it would have been better if it were the same color as your head crown.

Brie: Nice outfit. Love the rocks in the background.

Alicia: Very nice! Love the pose and all!

Candace: Small, but at least I can tell its Candace. Nice suit, and pose.

Eve: It's so small I can't even tell if that's Eve or not! Good use of the beach tho!

Velvet: Looks fun. Makes me want to go swimming.

Layla: Not your best photo. But it does stick with the theme.

Rosa: Best photo this week! I love it!

AJ: She looks really uncomfortable.

Maryse: Like the bikini

Beth: Love the blue color of the bikini, though the headband looks really weird in the picture.

Brie


Alicia


Candace


Velvet


Layla


Rosa


AJ


Maryse


Beth

Brie: Looks like you got a little street cred, hun. Cute pic and still sexy.
Alicia: Honestly, i never was a fan of that 'thing' on your head. It looks dumb to me. You look nice though.
Candace: My first thought was 'saddle me up'
Velvet: Love the shades. Simple and sexy
Layla: The shades just make the outfit even more seductive.
Rosa: DAMN!! all i can say is...damn!
AJ: Cute and Innocent. Yet, You look a little more mature.
Maryse: You make me want to commit a crime.
Beth: Aww old school

Silva, the headband she wears didn't count.

It was hats, sunglasses, glasses or bandanas

Brie: This is one of my favorite photos this week. It is really cute.
Alicia: It looks like a dead animal, but the whole outfit is fierce!
Candice: The black background goes good with the contrast of her outfit.
Velvet: She looks like she can just hang out and go shopping, cute pic. The sunglasses are nice!
Layla: Like Vix said very seductive.
Rosa: Very cute, yet very simple.
AJ: Her best picture so far IMO. Very cute and innocent looking.
Maryse: Her pics never seem to disappoint.
Beth: This is Beth's worst photo so far. But it's not really horrible either.

Special Challenge Photos

Nikki


Beth


Eve


Kelly Kelly


Kaitlyn


Winter


Natalya


Brooke

Blue Jeans/Shorts/Skirts Redemption Round!

Nikki: I don't care for the picture much. Her face looks weird the way it is turned and I don't like the pose. The jeans are good enough I suppose and I like the silver top. The couch looks comfy though. :p Overall though not my favorite.

Beth: I think Beth's face is very strong like usual and I actually really like the attire I just wish her boobs were not out so much since it looks trashy and Beth should be above that.. Again with the black leather furniture! Beth and Nikki should be sitting right next to each other that chair looks like part of a set with the couch. Anyways.. Beth's picture is one of my favorites I just think that the jeans are not really shown much and this is jean challenge. :-/

Eve: The setting makes me want to give Eve some purell.. She looks good though. I usually don't like ripped worn out jeans but the white in the jeans matches her white shirt. I will say that I don't like the way her right arm is positioned and I dislike how her mouth is open.

Kelly: The picture is pretty simply. I don't like the background [mainly the part by her feet since it looks odd]. Again ripped jeans are not my thing but like in Eve's case the white from the ripped jeans works with other areas of white in the attire [shirt/boots].

Kaitlyn: Shorts are different so I'll give her some credit there but these shorts are really short and she looks trashy! It doesn't help that she is wearing that bandana and those ugly shoes.. The background actually is one of the strongest parts of the photo for me. It makes her tiny shorts stand out. Oh and the shirt isn't bad it's just not enough imo..

Winter: Not a bad picture it just isn't memorable. The hat is unique and I do like the shirt however the picture is just average at best for me..sorry..

Natalya: Oh look it is Kelly's jeans from earlier! Not a great thing when that is what catches my eye first.. Nattie must not wear jeans much if this is the picture because it is just not good. I mean it is out of focus or something which causes her face to be hard to see much and her pose is awkward. At least you can see the jeans but they are nothing special. Sorry it is just not a good pic.

Tessmacher: This is a great picture and my favorite of the week! At first glance I hated the car because it looks nasty.. But the rusted color of the car actually stands out quite well and contrasts nicely with Brooke's blue jeans. The blue sky is very pretty btw so that only helps the picture out. Back to Brooke..she looks very good. Her body is in amazing shape and I like her attire, necklace, and hair. Great job.

Nikki: great pic but i wish i could see your jeans better

Beth: like nikki i want to see your jeans more. the top takes focus from the jeans, though.

Eve: You look beautiful

Kelly: You look adorable

Kaitlyn: You can be my biker chick...just not with tose shoes

Winter: Great outfit and the hat is a nice touch.

Natalya: The top clashes bad and it looks horrific

Brooke: DAMN! just..damn you look amazing

Nikki: Really cute pose and outfit, the only thing I don't really care for is the facial expression.

Beth: Cute outfit!

Eve: Great picture! One of the best this week IMO.

Kelly: Nothing really special about this picture she's not really posing or there is nothing special about the background.

Kaitlyn: This is not a good picture of her at all.

Winter: One of the better pictures of her in this show so far.

Natalya: This is just not a good picture at all.

Brooke: This is an awesome photo, everything about it is great!

Challenge 8 Photos

Brie:


Alicia:


Candice:


Velvet:


Brooke:


Layla:


Rosa:


AJ:


Maryse:

Brie: The innocent look..i like. Great pose

Alicia: Sexy

Candice: Aww love the skirt..unique choice

Velvet: I love the ripped jeans look. so tomboyish but sexy

Brooke: Awww You look so cute.

Layla: You look amazing. Great choice!!

Rosa: Amazing..love the shoes too

AJ: Cute...no really feeling te socks/shos though

Maryse: wow...great attire and pose

Brie: Cute and simple. The shirt is really cute too.

Alicia: I like the pose its very unique.

Candice: Ewww ribs, too skinny. I like the use of the skirt, face and hair look weird though.

Velvet: I love her hair. Very cute and I like how the did the reflection thing.

Brooke: Not as good as her first jean picture but still good.

Layla: Her face looks weird but I like the picture.

Rosa: Cute

AJ: Everything she is wearing clashes.

Maryse: Great Photo!!

Challenge 9 Photos

Maryse


Brie


Rosa


Alicia


Layla


Velvet


Brooke


Candace
WAS A NO SHOW

wow...Alicia is very lucky to have survived this week

Challenge 10 Photos

Brie


Maryse


Alicia


Layla


Rosa


Velvet


Brooke

Brie: Cute. But I must say I don't like the face and the hair looks flat.
Maryse: Not her best picture. But the outfit is really cute.
Alicia: She looks like she can be a cocktail waitress at a Christmas party. Not bad.
Layla: To me this looks to be the least Christmas picture out of all. It just looks like winter lingerie.
Rosa: Nice pic!
Velvet: I bet boys would kill to sit on that lap. Nice use of the theme.
Brooke: Best pic of the week for me once again!